osu-wiki icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
osu-wiki copied to clipboard

beatmapping pages rework

Open NoffyNoffeh opened this issue 5 years ago • 6 comments

this is a thing that's happening slowly and surely

(clayton has heavily edited this list since the issue was opened)

  • [x] People > Beatmap Nominator pages
  • ~haven't been reviewed in a long time, potentially not up-to-speed with newer changes to internal BN stuff~ this has happened now.
  • Becoming a Beatmap Nominator needs additional information to help people get closer to the ideals of the "modding expectations" section. Either by adding to it or creating a guide which would be linked, such as a general all-modes version of this forum thread
  • [x] Adding a page about evaluations (#3135) (Noffy is working on this)
  • [x] Beatmap Discussion (#3126)
  • [ ] Beatmapping - mostly up-to-date but it's not written well. it should function as a decent hub for all things mapping related https://github.com/ppy/osu-wiki/issues/9025
  • [x] Difficulties https://github.com/ppy/osu-wiki/pull/4773
  • [ ] Guides pages that are relevant
    • [x] Adding Custom Hitsounds (#3127)
    • [x] Collab_Information - this has weird personal suggestions https://github.com/ppy/osu-wiki/pull/8955
      • [x] https://github.com/ppy/osu-wiki/issues/6657
      • [x] https://github.com/ppy/osu-wiki/pull/8952
    • [x] ~~Compressing_Files - mega outdated tools~~ TicClick: the current version of the guide looks up to date -- both Audacity, Handbrake, and ffmpeg are being actively developed (and there's been a couple of clean-up/update PRs)
    • [x] Getting your map modded - not very up-to-date, especially following pishi's edits to Modding https://github.com/ppy/osu-wiki/pull/5597
    • [ ] How to time songs - just an odd writing style, but this looks pretty thorough https://github.com/ppy/osu-wiki/issues/6757
    • [x] Music theory - it's good content, but feels like it could use a better home? who's going to go looking in Guides for this?
    • [ ] osu!mania mapping guide - mostly formatting and layout problems https://github.com/ppy/osu-wiki/issues/8979
    • [ ] setting the offset on the correct beat - maybe not necessary. or belongs better in a general article about timing
    • [x] videos from youtube - mega outdated tools (#3851)
  • [x] Submission
  • [x] ~~Submission >~~ Beatmap ranking procedure
  • [x] Modding
  • see #3128 for Beatmap Editor

All need to be reviewed, combined where possible (some pages may seem like duplicates of each other) and generally rewritten to be made up to date. Lots of outdated and conflicting information is currently floating around these pages.

Maybe adding a history page for good to know old info when that's all done too.

  • [ ] Review terms/grammar across the resulting pages and make sure they are consistent

NoffyNoffeh avatar Sep 27 '19 14:09 NoffyNoffeh

I'm gonna assign this to ~~October~~ ~~November~~ December =( but we'll probably need some help to complete it

cl8n avatar Oct 02 '19 06:10 cl8n

milestone never gets done on this lol

cl8n avatar Jan 18 '20 23:01 cl8n

im currently rewriting the Beatmap Discussion page. Should be a bit easier once that's done. A lot of this stuff overlaps heavily.

Pennek avatar Jan 28 '20 22:01 Pennek

I have a thing for Difficulties WIP thanks mr venix for reminding me to post. involves tying together "Difficulty Naming" from RC and some other jazz

cl8n avatar Jan 29 '20 23:01 cl8n

For stuff like Hitsounding it might be worth cross-referencing usermade guides, since there are quite a lot of those not directly related to wiki

Pennek avatar Jan 30 '20 13:01 Pennek

Difficulties (clayton is working on this)

is @cl8n still working on this?

TicClick avatar Jan 19 '21 01:01 TicClick