powsybl-core icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
powsybl-core copied to clipboard

GroundDisconnector not supported during CGMES import

Open miovd opened this issue 5 years ago • 3 comments

  • Do you want to request a feature or report a bug? Feature

  • What is the current behavior? GroundDisconnector are ignored during CGMES import.

  • What is the expected behavior? GroundDisconnector objects should be imported as switches during CGMES conversion.

  • What is the motivation / use case for changing the behavior? It is in CGMES documentation and could be used.

  • Please tell us about your environment:

    • PowSyBl Version: 3.2.0-SNAPSHOT
  • Other information It might be necessary to add another SwitchKind (either GROUND_DISCONNECTOR or OTHER) for switches that do not have defined type.

miovd avatar Jan 24 '20 14:01 miovd

Point of attention: At first glance, nothing prevents someone from creating a switch with the "GROUND_DISCONNECTOR" type between 2 busbar sections. However, it does not make any sense. Thus, using a new type of disconnector could be seen as a weak way to model ground disconnectors.

So-Fras avatar Oct 26 '23 19:10 So-Fras

Another way to model ground disconnectors is to add a new equipment "Ground" and a ground disconnector will just be a disconnector that connects a Ground to the topology.

Question: what kind of equipment would the "Ground" be? It does not look like an Identifiable or an Extendable. Would it be a Singleton? What would be its electrical properties?

NB: in the CGMES import and export, one would have to be careful when converting ground disconnectors. One object in CGMES becomes two objects in IIDM (disconnector + ground)

So-Fras avatar Oct 26 '23 19:10 So-Fras

There is another question about the loadflow calculation: what happen if we decide to close the ground disconnector? Do we take it into account? If yes, how?

NB: in the current configuration, I think that opening or closing the ground disconnector will have no effect on the loadflow since one side of the ground disconnector is connected to "nothing".

So-Fras avatar Oct 26 '23 19:10 So-Fras