"Open With" With Many Candidates Does not Show All and Won't Dismiss

[WillAyd]

I am trying to use "Open With" on a PDF file, which can be opened by many different applications. This is the resulting view:

I can double click or hit enter to select any of these options, but the modal never goes away and I have to quit the finder application altogether to get rid of it

[Thatoo]

I don't even have Document Viewer, nor Firefox in that list so I can't open in the proper app...

[iamkartiknayak]

Is it still an issue? I cannot reproduce this on my system. The scrollable list populates with proper buttons at the end of the list.