cosmic-files icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
cosmic-files copied to clipboard

[Feature Request] Add Finder-like column view of folder

Open Sciancisco opened this issue 11 months ago • 10 comments

Please add a column view à la Finder! I find it most efficient to visualize and navigate the filesystem.

Ever since switching to Linux, I missed that view. I also wonder why no DE except Pantheon (to my knowledge) implemented a column view.

Sciancisco avatar Mar 15 '24 13:03 Sciancisco

I came here to report the exact same thing — Miller columns!

I switch between macOS and Linux and this is THE feature that makes using Nautilus so much more painful than Finder. (Unfortunately, this feature has been rejected by the GNOME Nautilus team.)

Specifically, I really value being able to traverse complex folder hierarchies (useful esp. for development projects that have folders buried in folders buried in folders) with just my keyboard navigation keys without getting lost or disoriented.

Would love to see this in COSMIC Files.

12people avatar Mar 26 '24 19:03 12people

I'd like to add another vote for this. When using a Mac, I use the Finder's columns view constantly, and hardly ever use any other view. It's far more useful and important than all other views put together.

peastman avatar Apr 08 '24 14:04 peastman

We have strongly considered this, and it is very likely to be a feature.

jackpot51 avatar Apr 08 '24 15:04 jackpot51

I'm really glad to hear that!

If you're interested in considering some novel ideas, I think there's still room for innovation in file browsers. I have an idea for how the column and list views could be combined into a single view with all the benefits of both. Here's a mockup showing how I imagine it working. This was created by pasting together pieces of a few different Finder views.

When you first open a file browser you would get a standard list view like in Finder or Nautilus.

Screenshot 2024-04-09 at 5 29 11 PM

You could do all the things you expect in a list view: select which fields to display, sort by any field, expand folders. If you selected a file, an info panel would slide on from the right side, covering up everything except the Name column.

image2

If you deselected the file, the info panel would slide back off and you would get the full set of fields again. If you instead selected a folder, a new list view would slide in from the right side, again covering up everything except the names.

image3

As you got deeper into the hierarchy, the columns for the outer directories would get pushed off the left side. A horizontal scrollbar would let you scroll back through them. So it's like the column view, but each column is itself hierarchical and sortable, and the innermost directory always shows the full set of fields from the list view.

Just something to think about!

peastman avatar Apr 10 '24 03:04 peastman

Miller columns would instantly be a great sales point for cosmic, and get you a lot of converts from other DEs.

tveimo avatar May 04 '24 00:05 tveimo

would be cool to have ranger like key binding (hjkl) for navigation.

subash-ev avatar Jul 12 '24 15:07 subash-ev

I'm for this.

kmf avatar Aug 12 '24 17:08 kmf

Hi guys, I'd like to bring your attention to https://www.onecommander.com/ This one of the gorgeous miller column implementations (or file manager implementations)

(Looks way better in dark mode, sadly windows only 😅) image

lalishansh avatar Sep 17 '24 19:09 lalishansh

@lalishansh have you seen https://github.com/euclio/fm written in Rust

kmf avatar Sep 17 '24 19:09 kmf

@lalishansh have you seen euclio/fm written in Rust

yup, but never used it (i use gokcehan/lf for column like layout 😅) And use onecommander when working on windows.

lalishansh avatar Sep 26 '24 06:09 lalishansh