polyscias

Nice analysis @nrenner! I am perfectly fine with removing the grade3-5 alias but my opinion is, also with knowing this story, such an alias is fine. There are more tags...

> I have somehow missed the PR and related discussion. I will try to address it and generate new profiles, but after Aug 15, due vacation. That would be nice....

See also [brouter-web#669](https://github.com/nrenner/brouter-web/issues/669), can we add also: - railway=platform - public_transport=platform - man_made=pier The first two are accessible on foot and a pier is often a way to access a...

> But instead of deleting these lines we could just place dummy-values as placeholders I did some analysis of all profiles I could find, see https://github.com/abrensch/brouter/issues/416#issuecomment-1100707613, I think non-used values...

I had a look at lookups_no_major.dat, it looks nice to me. Let me run in the weekend a rd5 creation test with it. Based on the brouter_route_placeholder_dummy's I understand the...

I dd run mapcreation on a looksup.dat based on lookups_no_major.dat but with my proposed changes above. It looks good, the total size of all .rd5's did go from 7878.0 MB...

What I think would be ideal is if the App was updated that once people open the App to download/update segments, it detects there is a new lookup version, and...

> I also think that we should not support false tagging practices like this: > > * [tracktype=grade3-5](https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/tags/tracktype=grade3-5) > * [highway=traffic_signals;crossing](https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/tags/highway=traffic_signals%3Bcrossing) > * [traffic_sign:direction=forward;backward](https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/tags/traffic_sign%3Adirection=backward%3Bforward) > * [traffic_signals:direction=forward;backward](https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/tags/traffic_signals%3Adirection=backward%3Bforward) For tracktype=grade3-5 see...

Yes, it would be good to get this PR forward and such a Version Problem message is exactly what is needed. One suggestion: Instead of the word "data" I would...

> Adding [kerb=*](https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:kerb) to the lookup table would allow us to determine an appropriate penalty for `barrier=kerb`. The current lookups.dat has already wheelchair=* and in that light adding kerb=* would...