Is there a way to authenticate with Azure ACS and a certificate (App Only context) ?

[jcanquelain]

Hi, I have an application which currently queries SharePoint Online using App Only access, based on Azure ACS (following this documentation).

It is the only way I found to restrict permissions to one given SharePoint site, because Azure AD applications' permissions only allow Sites.*.All permissions (for instance Sites.ReadWrite.All), which is too wide for me, and not allowed by my Organization (this gives access to all SharePoint sites for the tenant).

I currently authenticate against https://accounts.accesscontrol.windows.net/{{TENANT_ID}}/tokens/OAuth/2, with grant type "client_credientials" + ClientId and ClientSecret. This works like a charm, I can access the SharePoint site without giving SharePoint application permissions at Azure AD level !

So far, so good !

However, I have a technical requirement change from security department, and I now need to authenticated using a certificate instead of ClientId + ClientSecret.

I searched for some time but couldn't find a way to use both ACS access + certificate.

I tried the following :

• PnP.Framework.AuthenticationManager().GetACSAppOnlyContext() : Works well with client id + client secret, but no overload for certificates
• PnP.Framework.AuthenticationManager.CreateWithCertificate() : Does not work, need Sites.ReadWrite.All permissions at AAD level
• Using MSAL, Microsoft.Identity.Client.ConfidentialClientApplicationBuilder.Create(ClientId).WithCertificate(certificate).(new Uri($"https://accounts.accesscontrol.windows.net/{Tenantid}")).Build() : Does not work, needs Sites.ReadWrite.All permissions at AAD level

I have no more idea... Is there some method that I missed, or a way to restrict permissions to one site using Azure AD ?

Thanks !

[jackpoz]

I use new PnP.Framework.AuthenticationManager(applicationId, certificate, tenant).GetContext(siteUrl) which is the same as your 2nd try PnP.Framework.AuthenticationManager.CreateWithCertificate() .

Which url do you pass to GetContext( ) ? is it the SPO site url ?

[jcanquelain]

@jackpoz Thanks for the idea. I tried it, but same result as the others : works with rights defined at AAD level, doesn't work with rights only set at site level.

I use SPO site URL in GetContext(). The looks URL like : https://<my_domain>.sharepoint.com/sites/<my_site>

[jansenbe]

@jcanquelain : ACS does not work with certs, Azure AD based auth does but is by default using a tenant wide permission. Sites.Selected today indeed only applies to Graph API calls but we're expanding that to support also SharePoint REST and CSOM requests...this should then unblock your scenario.

[jcanquelain]

Hi @jansenbe , thank you for your answer. I'll then wait and look forward for this support for SP REST and CSOM. Is there a feature / issue on the board I can subscribe to, to be notified when it will be released ? Thanks !