php
docs(docker): add an example of building distroless image
Related to https://github.com/php/frankenphp/issues/151, this PR adds an example about how building a distroless image for a Frankenphp project.
FYI, on https://github.com/dunglas/symfony-docker, it only saves ~24MB in the image size.
I think we could go even further by building our own distroless image with Bazel like they do here but for now, the doc is a good start.
I don't understand the point of this. If you want the smallest possible file size, you want to go for a static musl binary with a bare linux kernel system. Statically linking everything ends up much smaller than linking against shared libraries, because dead code is stripped out, rather than preserved for dynamic exports.
And at that point, you don't need Docker anymore.
What you documented here will most definitely blow up when you attempt to use anything that loads a shared library. The docker container links against all libraries dynamically. And by using bookworm as the base, it itself wouldn't even run on a real "distroless" image, only on the stripped debian ones, because it links dynamically against glibc.
Thanks for your feedback 🙏.
I don't understand the point of this. If you want the smallest possible file size, you want to go for a static musl binary with a bare linux kernel system. Statically linking everything ends up much smaller than linking against shared libraries, because dead code is stripped out, rather than preserved for dynamic exports.
The main benefit of distroless images are security and image size : getting only things needed guarantees a minimal attack surface as it contains only your app and runtime deps (no package manager/shell/debugging tools/not even an echo). The main purpose of this documentation is to help FrankenPHP users building secure and small images. Based on Frankenphp documentation, using musl leads to performance degradation compared to glibc and to weird bugs, so I didn’t even try. Using static-builder-gnu was my first guess, but AFAIK static-builder-gnu provides the last PHP version and doesn’t let you choose (I might be wrong on this).
And at that point, you don't need Docker anymore. What you documented here will most definitely blow up when you attempt to use anything that loads a shared library. The docker container links against all libraries dynamically. And by using bookworm as the base, it itself wouldn't even run on a real "distroless" image, only on the stripped debian ones, because it links dynamically against glibc.
You’re right, that’s why I’m using the same Debian version between builder and distroless stage and copying the entire shared library.
Do you have anything in mind that could help ?
Based on Frankenphp documentation, using musl leads to performance degradation compared to glibc
Very minimal when using mimalloc. Even with the default allocator, you're only going to notice differences in heavily threaded scenarios. Using higher optimisation options will yield you 10%+++ better performance over debians/ubuntus php distributions, not to mention PGO.
The gnu static builder supports the same options as the musl one.
Do you have anything in mind that could help ?
Not particularly, but this approach seems like it will inevitably break things at some point. If someone is so starven of storage space that 6mb less (vs alpine) make a difference, perhaps they shouldn't be using frankenphp with a 50mb footprint, plus php with a ~35mb footprint.