sistr_cmd icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
sistr_cmd copied to clipboard

Discrepant results between similar Salamae genomes

Open flashton2003 opened this issue 1 year ago • 1 comments

Hello,

We've isolated some subsp salamaes for one of our projects. I have a few questions about the SISTR output for these isolates:

sample cgmlst_found_loci cgmlst_matching_alleles cgmlst_subspecies o_antigen serogroup serovar serovar_antigen serovar_cgmlst O antigen prediction H1 antigen prediction(fliC) H2 antigen prediction(fljB) Predicted identification Predicted antigenic profile Predicted serotype average_depth snp_count indel_count N_count reads_cov Reference Organism from Esmie Salmonella genus
CQJ13L 330 129 salamae - B II 1,4,12,[27]:a:z39|II 4:a:z39 II 1,4,12,[27]:a:z39|II 4:a:z39 II 1,4,[5],12,[27]:b:[e,n,x] 4 a z39 Salmonella enterica subspecies salamae (subspecies II) 4:a:z39 II [1],4,12,[27]:a:z39 70.3072 40928 0 0 89.86 GCF_019339485.1   Salmonella species
CQJ127 330 134 salamae - B II B:-:e,n,x II B:-:e,n,x II 1,4,[5],12,[27]:b:[e,n,x] 4 z e,n,x Salmonella enterica subspecies salamae (subspecies II) 4:z:e,n,x II [1],4,12,27:z:e,n,x 62.4964 40202 0 0 89.21 GCF_019339485.1 Salmonella Typhimurium Salmonella typhimurium
  1. Neither of these samples have a prediction in the o_antigen column, but when I blast them against your database, they have quite a good match (97% similarity, >99% coverage) to "304|584|1,4,12,27|B" from the wzx database. Is this match not good enough to call the O antigen? Or is there uncertainty about record 304?
  2. They are quite similar results across most fields (and for my blast results against the wxy and wxz databases), but they have different results in the output. How come?

Here are the fasta files, in case you want to dig in.

https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/ppkiflqyvtwrn28nah9s6/CQJ127_S25_L001.fna?rlkey=t19wktth1uguutnmqkuej3jq7&dl=0 https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/k4yg4iwo1k0mjdinyahx0/CQJ13L_S23_L001.fna?rlkey=woawgupve273z3b7y7tx2xipi&dl=0

Thanks,

Phil

flashton2003 avatar Aug 11 '23 08:08 flashton2003