Telegram icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
Telegram copied to clipboard

Videos are black - just hearing sound

Open Tuginho opened this issue 8 years ago • 17 comments

On my iOS Device I've some issues with the video playback. For some reason, the video screen is just black but I can hear the sound. For the Desktop App it work's well.

nachrichten-bild 2273206839

Tuginho avatar Nov 02 '16 13:11 Tuginho

+1

amin3mej avatar Feb 17 '17 20:02 amin3mej

+1

ghost avatar Apr 12 '17 10:04 ghost

This issue still exists in the current version when videos were sent from Android.

andrenarchy avatar May 14 '17 15:05 andrenarchy

Can reproduce it with a friend. If I send a video (from an Android phone), my friend cannot play the video (on an iOS phone).

FrankBro avatar May 28 '17 19:05 FrankBro

I can reproduce it too, there is any update on this?

TommasoScalici avatar Jul 02 '17 15:07 TommasoScalici

+1

dgigel avatar Jul 14 '17 20:07 dgigel

same problem sending mkv videos from apibot to IOS system, in android or desktop works well.

Overbull avatar Nov 15 '17 18:11 Overbull

Same problem, Can we do something to fix it?

cespar avatar Nov 15 '17 21:11 cespar

I can reproduce this too

fuomag9 avatar Dec 03 '17 15:12 fuomag9

Same problem

mactrash avatar Jan 20 '18 01:01 mactrash

Can confirm, same happens when I sent from OnePlus 3T (Android 8.0 / Telegram 4.7.1) to my friends iOS.

Anything we can help to resolve this issue?

henkka avatar Jan 24 '18 16:01 henkka

Same problem here! Video Sent from Android 8.1 (OnePlus 5) to iPhone 6S.

Timmy93 avatar Jun 05 '18 14:06 Timmy93

There is the same problem. Sending videos from OnePlus 5 to iPhone 7 and it can't play it correctly, only black screen is shown.

Heash avatar Sep 24 '18 12:09 Heash

I've noticed this several times now and I decided to try it out from several friends' phones, all running the latest Telegram:

  • From my OnePlus 3T running Android 8.0: any video I take with either Telegram or the OnePlus Camera app are shown as black in any iPhone I sent it to through Telegram. This also applies to gifs created by Telegram (by turning sound off).
  • From a Nexus 6 running Android 8: videos and gifs sent to iPhones work OK.
  • From a Pixel 1st gen running Android 9: videos and gifs sent to iPhones work OK.
  • From a OnePlus 6 running Android 9: videos and gifs sent to iPhones work OK.

Could this be an issue with Android 8-based OxygenOS (OnePlus) and Telegram? Has anyone reproduced this on non-OnePlus devices? Any workarounds? Anything I can do to help debug this?

edraac avatar Oct 17 '18 17:10 edraac

Has anyone reproduced this on non-OnePlus devices?

Same problem on Xiaomi mi 5s (Android 7.0, miui 9.6)

dgigel avatar Oct 19 '18 08:10 dgigel

Same problem, when I send video to iOS from LG G6 (Android 8.0)

kolyambo avatar Feb 17 '19 14:02 kolyambo

when I use ffmpeg to convert the video, I have the same problem.

Here is ffmpeg cmd:

ffmpeg -i input.mp4  -framerate 30  -vcodec libx264 -profile:v main -level 3.1 -preset medium -crf 23 -x264-params ref=4 -acodec copy -movflags +faststart -- output.mp4

The converted video will play very well on Telegram of Android, but when playing on Telegram IOS it's a black screen with voice. If I save the video to gallery from the channel, the video will be play very well with default video player of IOS.

Any idea and do you know what is best and valid ffmpeg command to convert a video to playable on Telegram of IOS?

Thanks.

omidraha avatar Feb 22 '19 03:02 omidraha