particl-desktop icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
particl-desktop copied to clipboard

Buyer Review not Showing Up in Q&A Section

Open cryptoguard opened this issue 3 years ago • 2 comments

Describe the bug Bought some listing from someone and left a review in the buy flow after marking the item as delivered. The review does show up in the order tile (in Purchases), but not when clicking on the listing in BROWSE, and then checking the Comments and Reviews section.

To Reproduce Steps to reproduce the behavior:

  1. Purchase an item and complete the entire process
  2. Leave a review when prompted to
  3. Verify the review has been published (if you see your review in your PURCHASES order)
  4. Check if you see your review in the Comments and Reviews section of the listing (in BROWSE)

Expected behavior The review should show up in the Comments and Reviews section.

Screenshots

20-May-2021-14-58-26

20-May-2021-14-58-43

Versions (please complete the following information):

  • OS: Linux Mint (5.11.10-051110-generic)
  • Particl Desktop: 3.0.0-RC-test003
  • Particl Core:0.19.2.8

Additional context Add any other context about the problem here.

cryptoguard avatar May 20 '21 19:05 cryptoguard

The "review" at the end of the buyflow step is not by design included in the general review section for the listing item. It is more a private note from the buyer to the seller after receiving the item... perhaps a personal thankyou for ensuring speedy delivery, or a note on some general improvements.

In no way is this meant to reflect in the public review commentary on the associated listing item: it would become difficult to determine whether the note is intended to be private for the seller only, or made publicly available, and would also inadvertently leak knowledge about the purchase having occurred.

Hence, this is not a bug, it is by design this way currently.

zaSmilingIdiot avatar May 20 '21 19:05 zaSmilingIdiot

I'm willing to leave this open though as a possible suggestion for a future version in which we perhaps allow the option for the user to publicly publish their review comment as well, with appropriate commentary surrounding it.

zaSmilingIdiot avatar May 20 '21 19:05 zaSmilingIdiot