mosaic icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
mosaic copied to clipboard

"Needs more work" button for honest expert workspaces

Open brachbach opened this issue 5 years ago • 6 comments

So that in the contractor experiments, where there are multiple honest experts per tree all trying to avoid contamination, a contaminated honest expert can pass on a workspace.

Not critical but would be nice to have

brachbach avatar Jul 01 '19 18:07 brachbach

I'd also throw it in for malicious experts -- we plan to try out multiple malicious experts per tree, and it would be nice for participants to be able to say, "eh, I'd like another one of the malicious experts to take a crack at this"

brachbach avatar Jul 09 '19 18:07 brachbach

Mati pointed out: "If a summoned HE cannot work b/c of info contamination, and they cannot (or don’t know how to) skip the workspace, they might just close the tab. And then they wouldn’t be subscribed to email notifications, and might forget about Ought’s experiments for a few days."

brachbach avatar Aug 16 '19 02:08 brachbach

Liam also points out:

Is there a better way to let someone else see a workspace than just logging out without submitting an answer? I really don't like filling out top level ME workspaces myself -- I think with multiple MEs on the tree at least 2 MEs should look at the top level answer before the entire MT is committed to it

matiroy avatar Aug 31 '19 01:08 matiroy

So far I've been fine just logging out and logging back in later. Once someone else got my ME workspace, and once I got my own workspace back the next day.

LiamDonovan4 avatar Aug 31 '19 07:08 LiamDonovan4

@LiamDonovan4 I think you're likely to get the same WS again in general if you do that. IIANM, with our current set-up, another ME on the tree would need to take the WS for you to not be assigned to it again.

matiroy avatar Aug 31 '19 14:08 matiroy

Eric writes:

As ME, I'd like to be able to skip a workspace for a few hours or a day. I'm trying to confer with other MEs working on the tree (via the ME doc) before committing to a strategy, but I keep getting assigned the workspace that I'd like the other MEs to get instead. This makes it difficult to collaborate between MEs and continue working on other workspaces at the same time.

https://app.slack.com/client/T3L8K3NMT/CMVHF5HJ8/thread/CMVHF5HJ8-1567615838.024000

Another idea would be to have only one ME assigned, but give them a consulting team of unassigned people (on being able to assign no role: https://github.com/oughtinc/mosaic/issues/518). Plus the ability to snooze a workspace.

matiroy avatar Sep 04 '19 17:09 matiroy