otsaloma
High resolution video files (>=2160p) are extremely stuttery and slow the app
When trying to load a larger video file in the player with Ctrl+L, the video plays very sloppily (ie lags, frame drops, stuttering etc.) I've found that this happens on videos bigger than ~250-300 MB but the threshold will probably vary from machine to machine.
I should note that my PC is powerful enough to watch 5-6 GB 4k videos in regular mpv at a mostly constant framerate:
I am using mpv as my player in gaupol, with the default command line. I tested many different files (.avi and .mp4, 30/60 fps, etc) both in gaupol and regular mpv, and there is a clear difference as regular mpv does not have any problems playing large video files. I also tried this with VLC and mplayer and the problem seems to persist.
Steps to reproduce:
- Open any subtitle file (.srt, .vtt, etc)
- Load a video file into the player (Video > Load Video... > select a large video (300-400 MB or above, any format should do)
- Attempt to play the video
Specs:
OS: Solus x86_64
Host: Aspire A515-51G V2.02
Kernel: 6.1.5-229.current
Uptime: 40 mins
Packages: 1220 (eopkg), 19 (flatpak)
Shell: bash 5.1.16
Resolution: 1366x768
DE: GNOME
WM: Mutter
WM Theme: Adwaita-dark
Theme: Adwaita [GTK2/3]
Icons: gnome [GTK2/3]
Terminal: gnome-terminal
CPU: Intel i5-8250U (8) @ 3.400GHz
GPU: NVIDIA GeForce MX150
GPU: Intel UHD Graphics 620
Memory: 2471MiB / 7831MiB
Debug info:
gaupol --version: gaupol 1.11
gaupol.conf:
[application_window]
layout = HORIZONTAL
maximized = true
position = [342, 163]
show_main_toolbar = false
size = [783, 470]
# toolbar_style = ICONS
[capitalization]
# country = ""
# language = ""
# script = "Latn"
[common_error]
# classes = ["Human", "OCR"]
# country = ""
# language = ""
# script = "Latn"
[duration_adjust]
# gap = 0.0
# lengthen = true
# maximum = 6.0
# minimum = 1.5
# shorten = false
# speed = 15.0
# target = CURRENT
# use_gap = true
# use_maximum = false
# use_minimum = true
[editor]
# custom_font = "monospace"
# field_order = [NUMBER, START, END, DURATION, MAIN_TEXT, TRAN_TEXT]
# framerate = FPS_23_976
# length_unit = EM
# mode = TIME
# show_lengths_cell = true
# show_lengths_edit = true
# stretch_length = 0.05
# use_custom_font = true
# use_zebra_stripes = true
# visible_fields = [NUMBER, START, END, DURATION, MAIN_TEXT]
[encoding]
# fallback = ["utf_8", "cp1252"]
# try_auto = true
# try_locale = true
# visible = ["utf_8", "cp1252"]
[extensions]
active = ["custom-framerates"]
[extensions::custom_framerates]
# framerates = [48.0]
[file]
# align_method = POSITION
directory = "/home/user/Video/YouTube/.sottotitoli"
# encoding = "utf_8"
# format = SUBRIP
# newline = UNIX
[framerate_convert]
# target = CURRENT
[general]
# dark_theme = false
# diff_color_change = "#ffff0033"
# diff_color_delete = "#ff555533"
# diff_color_insert = "#00ff0033"
version = "1.11"
[hearing_impaired]
# country = ""
# language = ""
# script = "Latn"
[join_split_words]
# join = true
# split = false
[line_break]
# country = ""
# language = ""
# length_unit = EM
# max_length = 24
# max_lines = 3
# script = "Latn"
# skip_max_length = 24
# skip_max_lines = 3
# use_skip_max_length = true
# use_skip_max_lines = true
[position_shift]
# target = CURRENT
[position_transform]
# target = CURRENT
[preview]
custom_command = "mpv --quiet --osd-level=2 --hr-seek=yes --start=$SECONDS --sub-file=$SUBFILE --sub-codepage=utf-8 $VIDEOFILE"
# force_utf_8 = true
# offset = 1.0
# player = MPV
# use_custom_command = false
[recent]
# show_not_found = false
[search]
# fields = [MAIN_TEXT]
# ignore_case = true
# regex = false
# target = CURRENT
[spell_check]
# field = MAIN_TEXT
inline = true
# language = "en"
# size = [500, 309]
# target = CURRENT
[subtitle_insert]
# above = false
[text_assistant]
# field = MAIN_TEXT
# maximized = false
pages = ["common-error"]
# remove_blank = true
size = [763, 433]
# target = CURRENT
[video_player]
# autoplay = true
# context_length = 1.0
# line_alignment = "center"
seek_length = 10.0
# subtitle_alpha = 1.0
subtitle_background = false
# subtitle_color = "#ffffff"
subtitle_font = "Cantarell 14"
# subtitle_position_horizontal = "center"
# subtitle_position_vertical = "bottom"
# time_alpha = 1.0
# time_background = true
# time_color = "#ffffff"
# time_font = "Monospace 14"
# time_position_horizontal = "right"
# time_position_vertical = "top"
# volume = null
Unfortunately i'm not able to test this on other machines or OS right now, but I will try to investigate on whether this is my issue or a Solus issue or something else. I'll also try to look into the code to see if I can help in any way :)
Hi, a couple thoughts on this
- I don't see how the file size would matter. If there's a difference between files, it would be about the container (MP4, Matroska, etc.), video codec (XviD, x264, etc.) or bitrate.
- The built-in video player in Gaupol uses GStreamer. The external video player (Tools / Preview) uses mpv, vlc or other such players. Thus you can check that you have needed GStreamer plugins installed, they are listed in the README.
- Gaupol does use GStreamer somewhat inefficiently (see https://github.com/otsaloma/gaupol/commit/dee6b6544e6ba2d26f287d46a13a731c48fa1c9f). On my own 7 year old desktop, I can play 1080p video just fine, so it's not that bad. The benefit we get with the simple gtksink is that, unlike faster, accelerated setups, this works out of the box on different hardware and X vs. Wayland etc. in 99% of cases.
- There's a minimal stand-alone player script in the source tree, which might help if you want to test a lot of different video: https://github.com/otsaloma/gaupol/blob/master/tools/play
Your screenshot seems to have 2160p video. I don't know if I have that high resolution at hand, but I can find something and test myself too. The bitrate isn't high though, I'm not sure if the resolution alone matters much.
Tried it now on a 2160p 7900 kbps video file. I confirm the stuttering playback, for me it even eventually freezes completely. Using GST_DEBUG=2 gaupol I see
0:00:04.668633807 605475 0x7fa85c012460 WARN audio-resampler audio-resampler.c:274:convert_taps_gint16_c: can't find exact taps
0:00:20.710288294 605475 0x7fa85c0eb890 WARN pulse pulsesink.c:704:gst_pulsering_stream_underflow_cb:<pulsesink0> Got underflow
0:00:33.649370387 605475 0x7fa85c0eb890 WARN pulse pulsesink.c:704:gst_pulsering_stream_underflow_cb:<pulsesink0> Got underflow
0:00:33.776172477 605475 0x7fa85c0eb890 WARN pulse pulsesink.c:716:gst_pulsering_stream_overflow_cb:<pulsesink0> Got overflow
0:00:33.776198960 605475 0x7fa85c0eb890 WARN pulse pulsesink.c:716:gst_pulsering_stream_overflow_cb:<pulsesink0> Got overflow
0:00:33.776213881 605475 0x7fa85c0eb890 WARN pulse pulsesink.c:716:gst_pulsering_stream_overflow_cb:<pulsesink0> Got overflow
0:00:33.776231532 605475 0x7fa85c0eb890 WARN pulse pulsesink.c:716:gst_pulsering_stream_overflow_cb:<pulsesink0> Got overflow
0:00:33.776248865 605475 0x7fa85c0eb890 WARN pulse pulsesink.c:716:gst_pulsering_stream_overflow_cb:<pulsesink0> Got overflow
0:00:33.776261598 605475 0x7fa85c0eb890 WARN pulse pulsesink.c:716:gst_pulsering_stream_overflow_cb:<pulsesink0> Got overflow
It would be useful if you or someone could help test whether it's the audio or video and resolution or bitrate, i.e. repack a video with and without audio, with and without video, downscale resolution keeping high bitrate, lower bitrate keeping resolution.
I'm also open to suggestions on how to setup the GStreamer pipeline differently to get better performance, but I'd still like it to work across different systems. The smallest, most conservative change would probably be some of the playbin settings (see gst-inspect-1.0 playbin).
Anyone needing a workaround, recode the video 1080p or lower (or download a different variant, whatever your source is for the video).
The built-in video player in Gaupol uses GStreamer. The external video player (Tools / Preview) uses mpv, vlc or other such players.
Sorry for the confusion 😅 I didn't know the difference between the F5 preview and the inline preview.
It would be useful if you or someone could help test whether it's the audio or video and resolution or bitrate, i.e. repack a video with and without audio, with and without video, downscale resolution keeping high bitrate, lower bitrate keeping resolution.
I did experience stuttering on some videos ripped from YouTube (downloaded with youtube-dl at max quality in .mp4). Most of them have ~4-5Mbps bitrates. Here's an example of the video that I originally had problems with:
After reducing the bitrate to ~800Kbps, the video played smoothly in Gaupol with basically no noticeable quality difference.
Maybe a solution to this would be to play back the video at a lower resolution/bitrate automatically (like a proxy in video editors). Since the size of the preview panel is pretty small, it wouldn't cause any noticeable difference and besides, given this use case, performance/framerate would be much more important than quality. The downside would probably be the added wait time before loading the video, which could vary a lot depending on the size, so it'd have to be optional. I'll see if I can test something like that
Since the size of the preview panel is pretty small, it wouldn't cause any noticeable difference and besides, given this use case, performance/framerate would be much more important than quality. The downside would probably be the added wait time before loading the video, which could vary a lot depending on the size, so it'd have to be optional.
I agree, I think these 2160p videos are way more than needed when just subtitling. But rather than having some kind of a lengthy pre-processing step, it should really be part of the GStreamer pipeline so it's done on the fly – if possible, that is.