name-suggestion-index icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
name-suggestion-index copied to clipboard

Add operator Technisches Hilfswerk / THW (German Federal Bureau of ```emergency=disaster_response```)

Open qugebert opened this issue 1 year ago • 5 comments

https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q697698

I would prefer adding only the operator-Tags, because the name-Tag is often used for the local organisation Name, e.g. "name=THW Ortsverband München Ost",

  • operator=Bundesanstalt Technisches Hilfswerk
  • operator:short_name=THW
  • operator:wikidata=Q697698
  • emergency=disaster_response

qugebert avatar Feb 08 '24 11:02 qugebert

@qugebert What do you think of using the brand key instead? See e.g. NSI's emergency=ambulance entries for reference.

kjonosm avatar Feb 08 '24 22:02 kjonosm

@qugebert What do you think of using the brand key instead? See e.g. NSI's emergency=ambulance entries for reference.

I guess brand is fine too, if that's common practice here. Can we exclude name here too? Because most of the existing places already have a extended name (with local branch / "Ortsverband") in the name, i think it would be good to preserve this. Edit: operator was my first suggestion, because it was used in this related PR https://github.com/osmlab/name-suggestion-index/pull/9221

qugebert avatar Feb 08 '24 22:02 qugebert

@qugebert Following https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/richtige-erfassung-von-liegenschaften-des-technischen-hilfswerks/108790/29 I think using operator is fine. Has there been an agreement on which exact value to use?

kjonosm avatar Feb 09 '24 14:02 kjonosm

Oops, i didn't recognize this thread There is a poll for a unique operator value, I keep you updated after that poll is over.

qugebert avatar Feb 09 '24 15:02 qugebert

Ok, so we can take

operator=Bundesanstalt Technisches Hilfswerk
operator:short=THW
operator:wikidata=Q697698
emergency=disaster_response

This template should only apply to the local branch (probably name "THW Ortsverband"), as THW operates other facilities too (regional bureaus,academies,logistic centres,etc.), where the tagging emergency=disaster_response would not fit. But these might become their own tagging schema in the future, see (https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Proposal:Emergency%3Ddisaster_response#Future_plans)

grafik The operator:short_name in the poll was a mistake, we should use operator:short as this is the common tag.

qugebert avatar Feb 18 '24 18:02 qugebert