editor-layer-index icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
editor-layer-index copied to clipboard

IBGE layers are borked

Open naoliv opened this issue 3 years ago • 11 comments

IBGE Mapa de Setores Urbanos and IBGE Mapa de Setores Rurais are borked, due to https://blog.mapbox.com/deprecating-studio-classic-styles-d8892ac38cb4

While trying to use any of these layers it's possible to see:

Classic styles are no longer supported; see https://blog.mapbox.com/deprecating-studio-classic-styles-d8892ac38cb4 for more information

naoliv avatar Mar 10 '21 01:03 naoliv

@tmpsantos

naoliv avatar Mar 10 '21 01:03 naoliv

Hi @naoliv, thanks for flagging. I'm wondering if this layer is useful at all after the work you have done with the shapefiles. Should we deprecate them?

tmpsantos avatar Mar 10 '21 01:03 tmpsantos

It's not deprecated, i use there. Thanks @naoliv

tarcisiooliveira avatar Mar 10 '21 01:03 tarcisiooliveira

The Cartas Topográficas do Exército Brasileiro layer is very similar to IBGE Mapa de Setores Rurais.

But IBGE Nomes de Ruas and IBGE Mapa de Setores Urbanos aren't 1:1 equivalent; some data is available only in IBGE Mapa de Setores Urbanos.

naoliv avatar Mar 10 '21 01:03 naoliv

Just to summarize the current situation:

IBGE Mapa de Setores Urbanos and IBGE Mapa de Setores Rurais are borked, due to https://blog.mapbox.com/deprecating-studio-classic-styles-d8892ac38cb4

Both of these sources point to the mapbox account tmpsantos, which I assume is managed by @tmpsantos Will these sources be restored or should they be removed from ELI?

rbuffat avatar Mar 28 '21 19:03 rbuffat

FYI, there seems to be quite a lot of broken IBGE sources in ELI at the moment: https://rbuffat.github.io/eli_watchdog/ -> south-america -> south-america / br

rbuffat avatar Mar 28 '21 19:03 rbuffat

Will these sources be restored or should they be removed from ELI?

Let's remove them, they won't be restored.

tmpsantos avatar Mar 29 '21 14:03 tmpsantos

Could restore these layers, it is very useful for an OpenStreetMap Brasilieira community ?

eduardoaddad avatar Mar 30 '21 14:03 eduardoaddad

@eduardoaddad I know :-(

But another thing we could do is regenerate a better map now that the vector data that this raster map is based at is now available. @naoliv is this something you can help?

tmpsantos avatar Mar 30 '21 15:03 tmpsantos

Unfortunately I am overwhelmed with life lately. I even intended to create more layers with other data from IBGE. But it won't be possible for now.

naoliv avatar Mar 30 '21 20:03 naoliv

@naoliv can you drop some pointers about what would be the source data to recreate this layer using vector data? I heard you have done some prior art in this direction. This would be extremely helpful for anyone wanting to move this forward.

tmpsantos avatar Mar 30 '21 22:03 tmpsantos