osmose-backend icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
osmose-backend copied to clipboard

Duplicate name error on official name

Open hlfan opened this issue 1 year ago • 3 comments

The official name of the Austrian A5 motorway is "Nord/Weinviertel Autobahn", which causes lots of reports of item 5030, class 705 on the map. Could a check be added to remove this when the way is in a route relation with the same ref and name or something like that?

hlfan avatar Dec 15 '23 10:12 hlfan

Not sure what to do with this case. Using "/" does not look like a common practice in the country. Half of the naming issues in the area are only for this motorway. There is about 200 issues for this motorway.

frodrigo avatar Dec 16 '23 19:12 frodrigo

I doubt that there will be many false negatives if elements of the same name and ref as a route relation in which they're a member are classified as a less important error or disregarded completely if that relation has a wikidata link.

hlfan avatar Dec 19 '23 15:12 hlfan

I doubt that there will be many false negatives if elements of the same name and ref as a route relation in which they're a member are classified as a less important error or disregarded completely if that relation has a wikidata link.

This idea please me. But it cannot be implement. This kind of check is done object by object without access to related object like the relation.

I think the only ways are :

  • allow '/' for the area
  • add this name as an explicit exception.

frodrigo avatar Dec 22 '23 16:12 frodrigo