routing icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
routing copied to clipboard

Remove or keep bird-openwrt packets?

Open p4u opened this issue 8 years ago • 5 comments

The bird integration to UCI/LUCI was made by Eloi, a student which is now out of the map. I pushed the packets to the oprnwrt-routing repository with the idea that he would maintain them, however I don't think it is gonna happen. Is there anyone interested on taking care of the maintenance? If not, I would remove them at least from the official repository.

https://github.com/openwrt-routing/packages/tree/master/bird-openwrt

p4u avatar Feb 21 '17 17:02 p4u

Dear Pau,

As you say, I have not been actively maintaining the package (lack of time). However, I just have started updating it as I could make it part of my MSc. project.

eloicaso avatar Feb 21 '17 18:02 eloicaso

Any plans to support Bird 2.0?

tohojo avatar Apr 03 '18 15:04 tohojo

Yes, I already started looking at it and how Bird2 manages configuration now. However, I have had no spare time yet to properly start developing it. Moreover, I am still unsure about how bird1/2 separation will be handled (https://github.com/openwrt-routing/packages/pull/340)

eloicaso avatar Apr 03 '18 20:04 eloicaso

Eloi [email protected] writes:

Yes, I already started looking at it and how Bird2 manages configuration now. However, I have had no spare time yet to properly start developing it. Moreover, I am still unsure about how bird1/2 separation will be handled (https://github.com/openwrt-routing/packages/pull/340)

Ah, awesome, didn't see that pull request. Not sure there's a reason to keep bird 1.6 around if you can support the 2.0 config format in uci. The upgrade cost is mostly in configuration file format changes...

tohojo avatar Apr 03 '18 21:04 tohojo

Please close this issue. Even when it is out of date, it is better than nothing.

BIRD2 appears to be built for 2.0.7 but is not in the release tree. Why is that?

briantopping avatar Mar 13 '20 22:03 briantopping

Hi @p4u,

I'm maintaining the bird1-openwrt packages now, so you may want to close this issue.

Cheers!

rogerpueyo avatar Mar 06 '23 22:03 rogerpueyo