iD icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
iD copied to clipboard

Add a button to the Mapillary field to set the value to the currently selected Mapillary photo id

Open RudyTheDev opened this issue 2 years ago • 15 comments

In addition, always show the mapillary field when a Mapillary photo is selected.

This would significantly simplify this action. Currently, one has to either (A) open the photo link, copy the id from the browser's URL bar, and close the tab, add the field, and paste the id into the field or (B) copy the photo link, add the field, paste the id into the field, and trim the non-id part from the URL.

This should encourage more use and promote verifiability. It would also make mapping with Mapillary in iD a little more usable. Without going into tangentials, it's not the easiest workflow at the moment.

It would also make sense to have a button to activate Mapillary layer and select the photo. Not sure how viable this is though - in general, one would have to query Mapillary API for the location of the photo, so this wouldn't be an instant action. Perhaps it may need to be restricted to those Mapillary photos that are currently loaded/visible.

RudyTheDev avatar Oct 20 '22 19:10 RudyTheDev

I also find it quite annoying that there is no easy way to add a Mapillary image tag to something when I am using the Mapillary layer inside the iD editor. I have to click on the mapillary icon to open the image in another window, then find the id and close the window again. It's such a waste of time and bandwidth. So it would be very nice if there was a quick way of getting the iD of the currently displayed Mapillary image within the iD editor

timothywashere avatar Oct 23 '22 21:10 timothywashere

@tyrasd Is this issue still open? It's my first time contributing in openstreetmap as this issue is labelled with good first issue , I would like to work on this.

Ni-vik avatar Nov 03 '22 13:11 Ni-vik

FYI, there is a comment of mine from Dez 2000 with some Wireframe-like illustrations of this feature idea https://github.com/openstreetmap/iD/issues/6196#issuecomment-751460516

tordans avatar Nov 03 '22 15:11 tordans

@Ni-vik are you working on this issue already? I would like to contribute as well, but I do not want to take an issue away if you are already working on it.

jdabapo avatar Nov 10 '22 16:11 jdabapo

@jdabapo yep I am working on it

Ni-vik avatar Nov 14 '22 14:11 Ni-vik

Hey is this issue still open if yes then I would like to work on this

kunjbosamia avatar Feb 01 '23 18:02 kunjbosamia

Hey!! I want to work on this issue. I'm new here so I'm really excited to start contributing. Please assign it to me.

Gua00va avatar Feb 15 '23 19:02 Gua00va

Hello Friends and folks, is this issue already fixed? If not I want to work in this issue

KishorKumarParoi avatar Apr 02 '23 04:04 KishorKumarParoi

Hello Friends and folks, is this issue already fixed? If not I want to work in this issue

no, it has not yet been implemented. go ahead @KishorKumarParoi

tyrasd avatar Apr 05 '23 14:04 tyrasd

Hey , Can I work on this issue ? @tyrasd

Moeinmn avatar Apr 30 '23 06:04 Moeinmn

@Moeinmn can we collaborate together, actually I am very new to solving open source projects.

KishorKumarParoi avatar May 01 '23 04:05 KishorKumarParoi

@KishorKumarParoi yes why not , i'm new to opensource too

Moeinmn avatar May 01 '23 18:05 Moeinmn

@KishorKumarParoi @Moeinmn can I also collaborate , actually I am also very new to solving open source projects.

N-45div avatar May 03 '23 20:05 N-45div

@RudyTheDev I would like to work on this issue.Kindly assign

shreya024 avatar May 13 '23 03:05 shreya024

@RudyTheDev I would like to work on this issue.Kindly assign

I don't have the ability to assign anyone to tasks/issues in this repository. I simply proposed this feature.

RudyTheDev avatar May 13 '23 10:05 RudyTheDev