iD icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
iD copied to clipboard

Tagging opening_hours for "shopping sundays" in Poland

Open krzemyczek opened this issue 7 months ago • 1 comments

Description

In Poland, shops are not open on all Sundays. Instead, there are designated "shopping Sundays" – see green Sundays. Currently, there's no easy way to map them, so no one does. As a result, opening hours on Sundays in Poland are just unreliable.

Solutions

  • Solution 1 (not an ID feature): The simplest approach would be to distinguish regular Sundays from shopping Sundays using labels like "Su" and "shopSu", for example.

  • Solution 2: Add a button in ID: "Open only on shopping Sundays", which would automatically select the applicable Sundays each year. Since these dates change annually, the mapping should update every year.

For more context: https://help.openstreetmap.org/questions/70080/tagging-opening_hours-for-niedziele-handlowe-w-polsce-shopping-sundays-in-poland

Screenshots

Example of sign with opening hours in Poland: Image Monday - Thursday: 6:30 -22:00 Friday - Saturday: 6:30 -23:00 Shopping Sunday: 8:00 -21:00

krzemyczek avatar Jun 02 '25 18:06 krzemyczek

There was a more recent discussion about shopping Sundays on the forum. I’d suggest engaging with that discussion first, to make sure there’s buy-in from the local and global communities, since a lot of stakeholders are involved in coordinating any change to the opening hours syntax, however minor.

1ec5 avatar Jun 02 '25 19:06 1ec5

Yeah, this definitely has to be discussed first to find a suitable tagging solution for such situations. There's nothing to do on the iD side in the meantime.

tyrasd avatar Jun 24 '25 12:06 tyrasd