openstreetmap
Allegedly 3 relations, 4 are shown
URL
https://www.openstreetmap.org/edit?node=12003612260#map=20/53.23114/-4.17875
How to reproduce the issue?
Click the link. Click on the cycleway to the right https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/1295390144 . "Relations (3) but 4 are shown
Screenshot(s) or anything else?
Which deployed environments do you see the issue in?
Released version at openstreetmap.org/edit
What version numbers does this issue effect?
2.29.0
Which browsers are you seeing this problem on?
Firefox
That way is part of 3 unique relations. Notice that it's part of "Lon Las Cymru" twice which most likely isn't correct.
https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/1295390144 was added twice to https://www.openstreetmap.org/relation/5487292
This seems like a data issue...
This seems like a data issue...
Absolutely - but the data issue is what I am trying to fix with iD!
I seem to be able to remove the duplicate assignment by either clicking on the first or second delete icon in your screenshot. Afterwards, the UI would list three relations and the title would also show "Relations (3)". Wouldn't this resolve the issue?
Maybe it would be better to edit the relation instead, since one duplicate way member appears at the very end of the relation member list (where it probably doesn't belong).
One more thing - iD doesn't tell me that a way is in the relation twice, only that it is in two relations that have the same name. This is because iD refuses to show relation numbers.
We have a ticket about that, probably multiple. But yes, when a relation is listed twice in the same list of memberships, or when an element is listed twice in the same list of members, an extra bit at the end indicating the ID would be reasonable. Better yet, hovering over one of the entries could highlight the other matching entries somehow.
Please - not something that depends on mouse hover. It's not discoverable and it discriminates against those less deft with a mouse, or using a trackpad without having got the hang of it yet.
iD doesn't tell me that a way is in the relation twice, only that it is in two relations that have the same name
This could be solved by collapsing the multi-membership like this:
This could be solved by collapsing the multi-membership like this:
That does say "it is in the same relation twice", but doesn't say what relation that is or whether that is a problem or not. The relevant issues for the first part are https://github.com/openstreetmap/iD/issues/10343#issuecomment-2324726977 and https://github.com/openstreetmap/iD/issues/8559 , and it's pointless to even think about the second part until those are resolved.
whether that is a problem or not.
Not quite sure if I can follow: How could the relation membership editor help to find out whether there is a problem? It already says that this particular relation is a route, where multiple membership is at least in principle allowed. Showing something else (like the ref or network tags, or even the relation's id) would not necessarily help with this, or would it?