OpenBK7231T_App icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
OpenBK7231T_App copied to clipboard
verified publisher icon openshwprojects

Sonoff IObroker testers needed! Basic compatilibity seems to work!

Open openshwprojects opened this issue 2 years ago • 30 comments

It seems to be working, but can you guys help with testing?

See video here: https://www.elektroda.com/rtvforum/viewtopic.php?p=20402248#20402248

openshwprojects avatar Jan 24 '23 14:01 openshwprojects

There appears only one object at the sonoff adapter: Sonoff_IO

I miss the object POWER to swich On and OFF. Version: 1.15.377

Hahnweiler avatar Jan 24 '23 15:01 Hahnweiler

@Hahnweiler very good, the power is not pushed to repository yet, check back in few hours. I will do a release then.

openshwprojects avatar Jan 24 '23 16:01 openshwprojects

Ready for testing, awaiting your release ...

christi-ko avatar Jan 24 '23 17:01 christi-ko

@christi-ko @Hahnweiler It really need testing. I created two brokers, one on my PC and that one works and second on VM and that VM one has issues. Not sure what's wrong. Usage:

  1. enable here: image
  2. set MQTT data for iobroker
  3. full reboot! Do restart, please
  4. it should appear: image
  5. both ways communication works https://imgur.com/a/SSim6Ii

openshwprojects avatar Jan 24 '23 18:01 openshwprojects

Works great now. I get some warnings but i can confirm that the communication works in both ways.

Sonoff_IO_2 Sonoff_IO_warn

Hahnweiler avatar Jan 24 '23 19:01 Hahnweiler

@Hahnweiler I know nothing about that broker, but I will try to fix warnings.

Btw, is this supposed to work for bulbs as well?

I just installed it today for you guys to fix the support so I don't know yet, I will check later today.

It turned out that only TELE was missing, 99% was done already.

openshwprojects avatar Jan 24 '23 19:01 openshwprojects

Hi, for me the transmission is working fine and most variables can be seen now. However 2 questions left.

1.) I am using a Power Plug which should send voltage and powerconsumption too, as i configured BL0937 also. But no message sent for those. Do i miss something in the confirguration to send them also, or is this still a bug?

2.) The shown load average is always 99 and the performance has become less responsive i think, but this might be a wrong impression.

2023-01-24 21_28_25-objects - iobroker - Persönlich – Microsoft​ Edge

christi-ko avatar Jan 24 '23 20:01 christi-ko

LoadAvg is a placeholder. It's not calculated yet.

I will investigate Power measurement tomorrow.

Please report any further issues.

openshwprojects avatar Jan 24 '23 21:01 openshwprojects

Power TELE added image

openshwprojects avatar Jan 25 '23 09:01 openshwprojects

Just tested the newest version. This includes all energy values required. Thank you very much for this great tool, now i can really use my powerplugs 👍

christi-ko avatar Jan 25 '23 16:01 christi-ko

Hi Use a socket with a T34 chip and I think it's great that I now only need one adapter with IOBroker, but there are some warnings in the log. Steffen

SteffenB71 avatar Jan 25 '23 16:01 SteffenB71

I can confirm the warnings:

Sonoff_IO_warn3

Hahnweiler avatar Jan 25 '23 16:01 Hahnweiler

Do anyone know whats the source of these warnings? I could fix them if I had any idea what they mean...

Now I will also include DHT results in TELE message. Temperature and humidity.

@SteffenB71 , hey, you have T34 chip device? We don't have such one on our list. Can you consider posting a teardown? https://openbekeniot.github.io/webapp/devicesList.html We can even send you a free gift (a SD card, a DIY hacker card, etc) for submitting one: https://www.elektroda.com/rtvforum/topic3950844.html

openshwprojects avatar Jan 25 '23 17:01 openshwprojects

It seems as if there come too many of the same messages. Every 2 minutes i get 12 entries and then one warning:

Sonoff_IO_warn5

Hahnweiler avatar Jan 25 '23 18:01 Hahnweiler

Whe i restart the Sonoff Instance: Sonoff_IO_warn6

And after some minutes only the messages you can see at my last posting

Hahnweiler avatar Jan 25 '23 18:01 Hahnweiler

i dont know if this ist normal or if this has someting to do with the debug messages at the iobroker: Sonoff_IO_warn7

Hahnweiler avatar Jan 25 '23 18:01 Hahnweiler

@Hahnweiler How did you manage that the messages only come to you every 120 seconds, to me they come every few seconds.

Is there somewhere that can be set like with Tasmota - telemetry period @openshwproject I'll have a look with the teardown. The T34 behaves exactly like the N. But I'll test the new flash method first. The T34 are installed in the BSEED series. Steffen

SteffenB71 avatar Jan 25 '23 19:01 SteffenB71

I can explain - currently it's hardcoded that SENSOR comes every 3 seconds and TELE comes every 120 or so (and also when changing relay states ofc). Those delays will be configurable soon

openshwprojects avatar Jan 25 '23 20:01 openshwprojects

I have the similar failure message, but my log says something different. I enabled loglevel "all"

Info:MQTT:Publishing val (216 bytes) to tele/DVES_BK7231_N1/SENSOR retain=0 Debug:MQTT:MQTT deduper sent 0, culled duplicates 0, culled too fast 0 Info:MQTT:Publishing val 236.338577 to DVES_BK7231_N1/voltage/get retain=0 Debug:MQTT:MQTT deduper sent 0, culled duplicates 0, culled too fast 0 Debug:MQTT:MQTT deduper sent 0, culled duplicates 0, culled too fast 0 Info:MQTT:Publishing val 0.007794 to DVES_BK7231_N1/current/get retain=0 Info:MQTT:Publishing val (216 bytes) to tele/DVES_BK7231_N1/SENSOR retain=0 Debug:MQTT:MQTT deduper sent 0, culled duplicates 0, culled too fast 0 Debug:MQTT:MQTT deduper sent 0, culled duplicates 0, culled too fast 0 Debug:MQTT:MQTT deduper sent 0, culled duplicates 0, culled too fast 0

christi-ko avatar Jan 25 '23 20:01 christi-ko

Those obk logs are 100% normal.

openshwprojects avatar Jan 25 '23 22:01 openshwprojects

I am not that sure, but it looks like the iobroker is sending a message back to the device and cannot get a connection. However, i attached a log of the iobroker set to debug status "silly" for the mqtt plugin. Maybe it helps:

sonoff.0 2023-01-26 19:34:42.316 warn Client [DVES_BK7231_N1] Message 59 deleted after 11 retries
sonoff.0 2023-01-26 19:34:42.316 warn Client [DVES_BK7231_N1] Message 60 deleted after 11 retries
sonoff.0 2023-01-26 19:34:42.316 debug Client [DVES_BK7231_N1] Resend message topic: DVES_BK7231_N1/voltage/get, payload: 227.636642
sonoff.0 2023-01-26 19:34:42.316 debug Client [DVES_BK7231_N1] Resend message topic: tele/DVES_BK7231_N1/SENSOR, payload: {"Time":"1970-01-01T00:00:00","ENERGY":{"Power": 0.000000,"ApparentPower": 0,"ReactivePower": 0,"Factor":0.000000,"Voltage":227.636642,"Current":0.000000,"ConsumptionTotal":270.451538,"ConsumptionLastHour":0.000000}}
sonoff.0 2023-01-26 19:34:42.316 debug Client [DVES_BK7231_N1] Resend message topic: tele/DVES_BK7231_N1/SENSOR, payload: {"Time":"1970-01-01T00:00:00","ENERGY":{"Power": 0.000000,"ApparentPower": 0,"ReactivePower": 0,"Factor":0.000000,"Voltage":228.622085,"Current":0.000000,"ConsumptionTotal":270.451538,"ConsumptionLastHour":0.000000}}
sonoff.0 2023-01-26 19:34:42.316 debug Client [DVES_BK7231_N1] Resend message topic: DVES_BK7231_N1/current/get, payload: 0.007840
sonoff.0 2023-01-26 19:34:42.315 debug Client [DVES_BK7231_N1] Resend message topic: tele/DVES_BK7231_N1/SENSOR, payload: {"Time":"1970-01-01T00:00:00","ENERGY":{"Power": 0.000000,"ApparentPower": 0,"ReactivePower": 0,"Factor":0.000000,"Voltage":227.513458,"Current":0.000000,"ConsumptionTotal":270.451538,"ConsumptionLastHour":0.000000}}
sonoff.0 2023-01-26 19:34:42.315 debug Client [DVES_BK7231_N1] Resend message topic: DVES_BK7231_N1/voltage/get, payload: 231.728683
sonoff.0 2023-01-26 19:34:42.315 debug Client [DVES_BK7231_N1] Resend message topic: tele/DVES_BK7231_N1/SENSOR, payload: {"Time":"1970-01-01T00:00:00","ENERGY":{"Power": 0.000000,"ApparentPower": 0,"ReactivePower": 0,"Factor":0.000000,"Voltage":228.745269,"Current":0.007794,"ConsumptionTotal":270.451538,"ConsumptionLastHour":0.000000}}
sonoff.0 2023-01-26 19:34:42.315 debug Client [DVES_BK7231_N1] Resend message topic: DVES_BK7231_N1/current/get, payload: 0.000000
sonoff.0 2023-01-26 19:34:42.315 debug Client [DVES_BK7231_N1] Resend message topic: tele/DVES_BK7231_N1/SENSOR, payload: {"Time":"1970-01-01T00:00:00","ENERGY":{"Power": 0.000000,"ApparentPower": 0,"ReactivePower": 0,"Factor":0.000000,"Voltage":228.129364,"Current":0.000000,"ConsumptionTotal":270.451538,"ConsumptionLastHour":0.000000}}
sonoff.0 2023-01-26 19:34:42.315 debug Client [DVES_BK7231_N1] Resend message topic: DVES_BK7231_N1/voltage/get, payload: 228.842071
sonoff.0 2023-01-26 19:34:42.314 debug Client [DVES_BK7231_N1] Resend message topic: tele/DVES_BK7231_N1/SENSOR, payload: {"Time":"1970-01-01T00:00:00","ENERGY":{"Power": 0.000000,"ApparentPower": 0,"ReactivePower": 0,"Factor":0.000000,"Voltage":229.484344,"Current":0.000000,"ConsumptionTotal":270.451538,"ConsumptionLastHour":0.000000}}
sonoff.0 2023-01-26 19:34:42.314 debug Client [DVES_BK7231_N1] Resend message topic: tele/DVES_BK7231_N1/SENSOR, payload: {"Time":"1970-01-01T00:00:00","ENERGY":{"Power": 0.000000,"ApparentPower": 0,"ReactivePower": 0,"Factor":0.000000,"Voltage":228.252548,"Current":0.000000,"ConsumptionTotal":270.451538,"ConsumptionLastHour":0.000000}}
sonoff.0 2023-01-26 19:34:42.313 debug Client [DVES_BK7231_N1] Resend message topic: DVES_BK7231_N1/voltage/get, payload: 229.331848
sonoff.0 2023-01-26 19:34:40.422 debug stateChange sonoff.0.DVES_BK7231_N1.ENERGY_ConsumptionLastHour: {"val":0,"ack":true,"ts":1674758080421,"q":0,"from":"system.adapter.sonoff.0","user":"system.user.admin","lc":1674664114742}
sonoff.0 2023-01-26 19:34:40.421 debug stateChange sonoff.0.DVES_BK7231_N1.ENERGY_ConsumptionTotal: {"val":270.451538,"ack":true,"ts":1674758080420,"q":0,"from":"system.adapter.sonoff.0","user":"system.user.admin","lc":1674757975536}
sonoff.0 2023-01-26 19:34:40.421 debug Set State after task: sonoff.0.DVES_BK7231_N1.ENERGY_ConsumptionLastHour
sonoff.0 2023-01-26 19:34:40.421 debug process task: {"type":"addObject","id":"sonoff.0.DVES_BK7231_N1.ENERGY_ConsumptionLastHour","data":{"_id":"sonoff.0.DVES_BK7231_N1.ENERGY_ConsumptionLastHour","common":{"role":"value","read":true,"write":false,"type":"number","name":"DVES_BK7231_N1 ENERGY ConsumptionLastHour"},"native":{},"type":"state"},"cbArg":0}
sonoff.0 2023-01-26 19:34:40.420 debug stateChange sonoff.0.DVES_BK7231_N1.ENERGY_Current: {"val":0,"ack":true,"ts":1674758080419,"q":0,"from":"system.adapter.sonoff.0","user":"system.user.admin","lc":1674758071416}
sonoff.0 2023-01-26 19:34:40.419 debug Set State after task: sonoff.0.DVES_BK7231_N1.ENERGY_ConsumptionTotal
sonoff.0 2023-01-26 19:34:40.419 debug process task: {"type":"addObject","id":"sonoff.0.DVES_BK7231_N1.ENERGY_ConsumptionTotal","data":{"_id":"sonoff.0.DVES_BK7231_N1.ENERGY_ConsumptionTotal","common":{"role":"value","read":true,"write":false,"type":"number","name":"DVES_BK7231_N1 ENERGY ConsumptionTotal"},"native":{},"type":"state"},"cbArg":270.451538}
sonoff.0 2023-01-26 19:34:40.419 debug stateChange sonoff.0.DVES_BK7231_N1.ENERGY_Voltage: {"val":229.36116,"ack":true,"ts":1674758080418,"q":0,"from":"system.adapter.sonoff.0","user":"system.user.admin","lc":1674758080418}
sonoff.0 2023-01-26 19:34:40.418 debug Set State after task: sonoff.0.DVES_BK7231_N1.ENERGY_Current
sonoff.0 2023-01-26 19:34:40.418 debug process task: {"type":"addObject","id":"sonoff.0.DVES_BK7231_N1.ENERGY_Current","data":{"_id":"sonoff.0.DVES_BK7231_N1.ENERGY_Current","common":{"type":"number","role":"value.current","read":true,"write":false,"unit":"A","name":"DVES_BK7231_N1 ENERGY Current"},"native":{},"type":"state"},"cbArg":0}
sonoff.0 2023-01-26 19:34:40.417 debug stateChange sonoff.0.DVES_BK7231_N1.ENERGY_Factor: {"val":0,"ack":true,"ts":1674758080417,"q":0,"from":"system.adapter.sonoff.0","user":"system.user.admin","lc":1674664114728}
sonoff.0 2023-01-26 19:34:40.417 debug Set State after task: sonoff.0.DVES_BK7231_N1.ENERGY_Voltage
sonoff.0 2023-01-26 19:34:40.417 debug process task: {"type":"addObject","id":"sonoff.0.DVES_BK7231_N1.ENERGY_Voltage","data":{"_id":"sonoff.0.DVES_BK7231_N1.ENERGY_Voltage","common":{"type":"number","role":"value.voltage","read":true,"write":false,"unit":"V","name":"DVES_BK7231_N1 ENERGY Voltage"},"native":{},"type":"state"},"cbArg":229.36116}
sonoff.0 2023-01-26 19:34:40.416 debug stateChange sonoff.0.DVES_BK7231_N1.ENERGY_ReactivePower: {"val":0,"ack":true,"ts":1674758080416,"q":0,"from":"system.adapter.sonoff.0","user":"system.user.admin","lc":1674664114724}
sonoff.0 2023-01-26 19:34:40.416 debug Set State after task: sonoff.0.DVES_BK7231_N1.ENERGY_Factor
sonoff.0 2023-01-26 19:34:40.416 debug process task: {"type":"addObject","id":"sonoff.0.DVES_BK7231_N1.ENERGY_Factor","data":{"_id":"sonoff.0.DVES_BK7231_N1.ENERGY_Factor","common":{"type":"number","role":"value","read":true,"write":false,"name":"DVES_BK7231_N1 ENERGY Factor"},"native":{},"type":"state"},"cbArg":0}
sonoff.0 2023-01-26 19:34:40.415 debug stateChange sonoff.0.DVES_BK7231_N1.ENERGY_ApparentPower: {"val":0,"ack":true,"ts":1674758080414,"q":0,"from":"system.adapter.sonoff.0","user":"system.user.admin","lc":1674664114720}
sonoff.0 2023-01-26 19:34:40.415 debug Set State after task: sonoff.0.DVES_BK7231_N1.ENERGY_ReactivePower
sonoff.0 2023-01-26 19:34:40.415 debug process task: {"type":"addObject","id":"sonoff.0.DVES_BK7231_N1.ENERGY_ReactivePower","data":{"_id":"sonoff.0.DVES_BK7231_N1.ENERGY_ReactivePower","common":{"type":"number","role":"value.power.consumption","read":true,"write":false,"unit":"var","name":"DVES_BK7231_N1 ENERGY ReactivePower"},"native":{},"type":"state"},"cbArg":0}
sonoff.0 2023-01-26 19:34:40.414 debug stateChange sonoff.0.DVES_BK7231_N1.ENERGY_Power: {"val":0,"ack":true,"ts":1674758080413,"q":0,"from":"system.adapter.sonoff.0","user":"system.user.admin","lc":1674757098392}
sonoff.0 2023-01-26 19:34:40.414 debug Set State after task: sonoff.0.DVES_BK7231_N1.ENERGY_ApparentPower
sonoff.0 2023-01-26 19:34:40.414 debug process task: {"type":"addObject","id":"sonoff.0.DVES_BK7231_N1.ENERGY_ApparentPower","data":{"_id":"sonoff.0.DVES_BK7231_N1.ENERGY_ApparentPower","common":{"type":"number","role":"value.power.consumption","read":true,"write":false,"unit":"VA","name":"DVES_BK7231_N1 ENERGY ApparentPower"},"native":{},"type":"state"},"cbArg":0}
sonoff.0 2023-01-26 19:34:40.412 debug stateChange sonoff.0.DVES_BK7231_N1.Time: {"val":"1970-01-01T00:00:00","ack":true,"ts":1674758080411,"q":0,"from":"system.adapter.sonoff.0","user":"system.user.admin","lc":1674590802356}
sonoff.0 2023-01-26 19:34:40.412 debug Set State after task: sonoff.0.DVES_BK7231_N1.ENERGY_Power
sonoff.0 2023-01-26 19:34:40.412 debug process task: {"type":"addObject","id":"sonoff.0.DVES_BK7231_N1.ENERGY_Power","data":{"_id":"sonoff.0.DVES_BK7231_N1.ENERGY_Power","common":{"type":"number","role":"value.power.consumption","read":true,"write":false,"unit":"W","name":"DVES_BK7231_N1 ENERGY Power"},"native":{},"type":"state"},"cbArg":0}
sonoff.0 2023-01-26 19:34:40.410 debug updateState sonoff.0.DVES_BK7231_N1.ENERGY_ConsumptionLastHour - 9
sonoff.0 2023-01-26 19:34:40.410 debug updateState sonoff.0.DVES_BK7231_N1.ENERGY_ConsumptionTotal - 8
sonoff.0 2023-01-26 19:34:40.410 debug updateState sonoff.0.DVES_BK7231_N1.ENERGY_Current - 7
sonoff.0 2023-01-26 19:34:40.410 debug updateState sonoff.0.DVES_BK7231_N1.ENERGY_Voltage - 6
sonoff.0 2023-01-26 19:34:40.410 debug updateState sonoff.0.DVES_BK7231_N1.ENERGY_Factor - 5
sonoff.0 2023-01-26 19:34:40.410 debug updateState sonoff.0.DVES_BK7231_N1.ENERGY_ReactivePower - 4
sonoff.0 2023-01-26 19:34:40.410 debug updateState sonoff.0.DVES_BK7231_N1.ENERGY_ApparentPower - 3
sonoff.0 2023-01-26 19:34:40.410 debug updateState sonoff.0.DVES_BK7231_N1.ENERGY_Power - 2
sonoff.0 2023-01-26 19:34:40.410 debug Set State after task: sonoff.0.DVES_BK7231_N1.Time

christi-ko avatar Jan 26 '23 18:01 christi-ko

Hi Are there any suggested solutions in the meantime, because I can't use the Sonoff integration like I can now. Thanks Steffen

SteffenB71 avatar Jan 31 '23 18:01 SteffenB71

Hi Stefan, you can reduce the log level for sonoff in the iobroker, not to show that messages. Anyhow it should work as intendet, at least it does for me ...

christi-ko avatar Feb 01 '23 11:02 christi-ko

Hello, I also had the warn messages in iobroker log... and the powerstatus is not send just in time when its switched.

What can I do to change this?

coltc50 avatar Dec 13 '23 15:12 coltc50

The warn messages still appear and changes on the openbeken device won't be shown in iobroker. Log shows the MQTT message was send but sonoff adapter on iobroker shows the message delete after XX retires messages. randomly it seems to update the states from time to time but couldn't find a pattern when it is doing it.

Technology89 avatar Dec 31 '23 10:12 Technology89

@openshwprojects

Hello, I'd like to continue helping here, as I've found the software to be really good so far. Currently, it seems there are issues with the communication for the Sonoff adapter (ioBroker). How can I assist to ensure the implementation works well?

PS: The same issue as described here.

image

Cheers P

pafade89 avatar Jan 18 '24 09:01 pafade89

Hey, i can confirm that problem. The communication with the sonoff adapter works well! But i got also this warn messages.

Is there any solution or does somebody know why this messages appear?

image

TPPTim avatar Feb 03 '24 22:02 TPPTim

I would love to help with that but I need more information. Can someone tell me specifically what should OBK include more in the MQTT publishes so this warning does not appear?

Related thread: https://www.elektroda.com/rtvforum/viewtopic.php?p=20944572#20944572

openshwprojects avatar Feb 04 '24 16:02 openshwprojects

I'm sorry, I don't know if that helps, but are there any information on the GitHub page of the adapter that could be helpful?

https://github.com/ioBroker/ioBroker.sonoff

pafade89 avatar Feb 04 '24 18:02 pafade89

@openshwprojects Issue was fixed in Sonoff adapter of IoBroker. You can close this issue #634

          fixed in next version

Originally posted by @Apollon77 in https://github.com/ioBroker/ioBroker.sonoff/issues/350#issuecomment-2131345063

Next Version is v3.1.0

pafade89 avatar May 30 '24 19:05 pafade89