Missing natural data

[Duke74]

A lot of data from osm key:natural is missing: http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:natural

For example I'm interested in :

• [ ] valley
• [x] cliff
• [x] bare_rock
• [x] scree
• [x] ridge
• [x] arete

Is it a choice not to include this in openmaptiles, to optimize the tiles size ? In this case should I use my own layers in order to add this data ?

(Edit by stirringhalo to add checkboxes)

[stirringhalo]

That's a tricky question, we'll have to see how large our current tile sizes are and see if its feasible.

[stirringhalo]

Will do ridge, arete, cliff and valley in a separate layer and PR.

[stirringhalo]

@klokan , @jirik Btw, these features need to be added to the styles.

[jirik]

BTW ridge, arete, cliff and valley are mapped as linear features (not polygon) and only cliff is currently rendered by osm-carto.

[kylebarron]

natural=spring is also not currently included. I added it in my own fork to the POI layer. Is this something you're interested in a PR for?

[kylebarron]

What about adding other point natural values to the mountain_peaks layer? I'm specifically thinking of natural=spring and natural=saddle.

[1ec5]

natural=mud and natural=dry_lake would also be nice to have. Large expanses of the Western United States are covered in one of these tags. It can be jarring when they’re missing from a map that otherwise shows wetlands and other natural features.