openfaas-cloud icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
openfaas-cloud copied to clipboard

[Feature request] Support GitLab container registry

Open khos2ow opened this issue 4 years ago • 1 comments

Current Behaviour

Currently there's no way to use GitLab container registry as part of the deployment, the reason is URLs of the registry are slightly different than the ones available in other registries (e.g. DockerHub).

  • GitLab: https://registry.example.com/group/project:tag
  • GitLab: https://registry.example.com/group/project/image:tag (extra /<foo> is valid in gitlab, up to three level deep)
  • DockerHub: group/project:tag (simplified for the sake of writing here)

The relevant part of the code is here:

https://github.com/openfaas/openfaas-cloud/blob/b1dc3f000168fabe0f7e795dfb240ca4f0534ba6/git-tar/function/ops.go#L204-L208

Note that imageName is being appended to repo by a -, which breaks gitlab registry. Considering the project exists at https://git.example.com/group/project:

  • Invalid: https://registry.example.com/group/project-latest-master-<sha>
  • Valid: https://registry.example.com/group/project:latest-master-<sha>
  • Valid: https://registry.example.com/group/project/fn-name:latest-master-<sha>

On the same topic and slightly different issue (let me know if you'd like me to open another issue for this), owner in the code above (line 205 and 207) in GitLab depends on the profile. Considering user name of khos2ow and full profile name of Khosrow Moossavi, owner will be set to full profile name which breaks the URL format. Considering the project exists at https://git.example.com/khos2ow/project:

  • Invalid: https://registry.example.com/Khosrow Moossavi/project:latest-master-<sha>
  • Expected: https://registry.example.com/khos2ow/project:latest-master-<sha>

Possible Solution

  • First issue: Intelligently choose / over - when building image only for GitLab container registry.
  • Second issue: haven't investigated further to see what would be available

khos2ow avatar Nov 26 '20 01:11 khos2ow

Thanks for raising this. The temporary patch I created for you which you tested out seemed to help with the format. As for usernames with spaces in, that would be a much bigger change, but not out of the realms of possibility.

alexellis avatar Dec 03 '20 09:12 alexellis