openfaas
Snap Package Support (Feature Request)
I was thinking in the install and setup could be improved for Ubuntu and other Linux distros by having a snap package version. If it's not a priority would you mind if I made the snap?
Hey @mikeroyal Although I personally use Ubuntu (and snaps) primarily, this isn't a priority for the project.
The challenge is in maintaining the versions with releases.
We currently only officially support brew installer on MacOS as that is the primary platform for our users. Even that can be a challenge to keep up with the changes.
If you could propose a way that the maintenance of the snap would be automated, and reliable, it may be something that could be considered. However, as of right now, I don't think this will come to fruition.
I don't mean to knock your idea. I do like the idea, it's just difficult to keep up with multiple installers in the long term...
Thanks for sharing your thoughts Burton.
@mikeroyal
Thanks for sharing your suggestion and for taking an interest in OpenFaaS. I'd like to see what the snap looks like and to understand what the maintenance effort would be like for the project. It sounds like you have bandwidth to put together a snap and I'd be interested to find out more.
On a related note, have you worked much with microk8s and do you know if that supports "add-ons"?
Alex
@alexellis, Yes, here are the docs if you want to read more in-depth. https://microk8s.io/docs/
List of available addons
dns: Deploy kube dns. This addon may be required by others thus we recommend you always enable it.
dashboard: Deploy kubernetes dashboard as well as grafana and influxdb. To access grafana point your browser to the url reported by microk8s.kubectl cluster-info.
storage: Create a default storage class. This storage class makes use of the hostpath-provisioner pointing to a directory on the host. Persistent volumes are created under ${SNAP_COMMON}/default-storage. Upon disabling this addon you will be asked if you want to delete the persistent volumes created.
ingress: Create an ingress controller.
gpu: Expose GPU(s) to MicroK8s by enabling the nvidia-docker runtime and nvidia-device-plugin-daemonset. Requires NVIDIA drivers to already be installed on the host system.
istio: Deploy the core Istio services. You can use the microk8s.istioctl command to manage your deployments.
registry: Deploy a docker private registry and expose it on localhost:32000. The storage addon will be enabled as part of this addon. To use the registry you can use the microk8s.docker command.
metrics-server: Deploy the Metrics Server.
Thanks so much for the info. Do you want to join Slack to talk more? https://docs.openfaas.com/community/
How do we go about writing a test snap for this?
Alex
Hi @alexellis, Sorry it took me a while to see your notification been busy. Anyways here's small repo I made for the snap. https://github.com/mikeroyal/faas-cli-snap
All that's left for me to do is finish up the snapcraft.yaml config file to make sure all plugins and dependencies are setup properly to build the application.
@mikeroyal hello there,
You currently own the faas-cli snap name, but we (the Snap Store team) received a request from the openfaas project to get ownership of the name. I wonder if you could confirm whether you agree with this in general (@alexellis is the requester).
I will also need to email you privately to confirm (as I can't verify your Snap Store email address matches your github identity) but it'll speed things up if you and @alexellis decide here whether it's OK to do the transfer.
- Daniel
Hi @mikeroyal I can see some releases and snapshots, we'd assumed there was no package and started work on this to resolve, but it looks like you had something up.
In the dashboard I see this error though
The above is because Mike's snap uses the docker interface which needs to be explicitly approved (you can request it in the forum: https://forum.snapcraft.io/c/store-requests.
Alternatively, if you make it so that the snap doesn't require use of docker, it would likely pass the automatic review process.
- Daniel