openbenches.org icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
openbenches.org copied to clipboard

Suggestion: Merge bench

Open backache opened this issue 3 years ago • 3 comments

I have created a duplicate bench, could there be a merge button to bring all the goodness of the two records together?

It'd be a shame if people are just deleting duplicates when a mistake could be turned into an enrichment of an existing record

backache avatar Apr 27 '22 07:04 backache

Heya, thanks for the suggestion. We do have a merge function, but it is locked behind an admin-only login for now.

At the moment, whenever a bench is uploaded, I get an email saying if it is a possible duplicate. So it isn't much effort for me to merge them once in a while.

Additionally, there are lots of things which look like dupes, which aren't. E.g https://openbenches.org/search/?soundex=I561354323 - I didn't want people accidentally merging them.

Finally, if you do spot a bench on the site and want to add more photos to it, there's an edit button at the bottom.

If you can think of a sensible way of letting regular user merge dupes, I'm happy to take suggestions or pull requests.

edent avatar Apr 27 '22 08:04 edent

Maybe give them a button/form to flag up the dupe that actually behind the scenes just alerts the admins somehow, or perhaps starts the process for an admin just to okay

btw the dupe I created I was

Mine (wrong side of the road) https://openbenches.org/bench/23448/

the one it should be merged into

https://openbenches.org/bench/15352/

backache avatar Apr 27 '22 10:04 backache

Cheers - I've merged them. We have a comment box at the bottom of each page. People usually use that to flag up duplicates, missing data, or incorrect inscriptions.

I'll have a think if there's a better way to do that.

edent avatar Apr 27 '22 10:04 edent