theyvoteforyou icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
theyvoteforyou copied to clipboard

Add names to the list of people on the policy page, so I don't need to recognize their faces to identify then

Open brtrx opened this issue 8 years ago • 6 comments

These could be added a links below each profile image.

The mock up below uses this page as a template: https://theyvoteforyou.org.au/policies/47

image

This will have the added benefit of clarifying that the ordering of members within a specific level of agreement is alphabetical (and not, for example, an indication of relatively stronger or weaker agreement with a policy). For example, Albanese is first because his name starts with A, and not because he's the strongest supporter of an NBN (using fibre to the premises).

brtrx avatar Mar 21 '16 05:03 brtrx

I concur and would suggest adding district name + full names together, for those who may not know who their MPs are

kategolden avatar Jun 17 '16 02:06 kategolden

I tried a version with just that, and it got too cluttered. They are one click away from that member's details, which isn't too bad. But, in the case where someone's looking for someone from their electorate, my recommendation is to add a live text filter that filters on name and electorate (and potentially also postcode). See #1091

brtrx avatar Jun 17 '16 05:06 brtrx

This issue has been automatically marked as stale because there has been no activity on it for about six months. If you want to keep it open please make a comment and explain why this issue is still relevant. Otherwise it will be automatically closed in a week. Thank you!

stale[bot] avatar Oct 13 '21 03:10 stale[bot]

👍 to this approach. I recall experimenting with adding their full name under the photos and that was even too cluttered.

mlandauer avatar Oct 20 '21 09:10 mlandauer

how about being able to flip from images to listed by names?

katska avatar Oct 21 '21 02:10 katska

how about being able to flip from images to listed by names?

This idea initially didn't appeal to me but I've come around. Here's why:

The only way we could reliably fit the person's name alongside (or under) the photo is if we just use their last name. This is a perfectly reasonable approach but one that actually is different then everywhere else we use MPs names. Everywhere (as far as I'm aware) on openaustralia.org.au and theyvoteforyou.org.au we use people's full name (e.g. Wendy Askew). This is a very conscious decision to keep the names informal and relatable. After all politicians are people, just like us, and we should remember that. By just using a last name we risk a weird kind of objectification I think.

So, I think being able to switch to a list of names is a reasonable workaround. It's not great but I think the alternative is marginally worse for very different reasons.

mlandauer avatar Jan 17 '22 00:01 mlandauer

This issue has been automatically marked as stale because there has been no activity on it for about six months. If you want to keep it open please make a comment and explain why this issue is still relevant. Otherwise it will be automatically closed in a week. Thank you!

stale[bot] avatar Aug 31 '22 05:08 stale[bot]