Pythonista-Issues
Pythonista-Issues copied to clipboard
omz
Scipy for Pythonista
The scipy library is a scientific computing library for Python. It integrates nicely with numpy, which is already included in Pythonista.
Including scipy with Pythonista would mean we'd have all the dependencies in place for the easy inclusion of lots of really powerful libraries like:
- scikit-image (advanced image processing and Computer Vision)
- scikit-learn (advanced machine learning library)
I can't believe nobody else is commenting on this. Yes, scipy and scikit-learn would make pythonista a dream come true for anybody who does scientific computing. It would be nice to have a comment from the author, wether this is an impossible feature to add or it just requires time.
@zaino No need to get angry :) If you check the language composition of scipy on GitHub (click on the multicolored bar under the commits/branches/releases/contributors links for detailed numbers) you'll see that over half of the code is not written in pure Python, but in compiled languages like C, C++ and Fortran. C and C++ are supported by the iOS development tools, which means that those parts would be reasonably easy to port. However @omz has said before (I think) that there is no Fortran compiler targetting iOS (aside from Fortran-to-C translators), which makes it basically impossible for him to port the 22.5 % of Fortran code in the repo to iOS.
Believe me, many people have requested the additon of scipy, but as I understand it it's not an easy thing to do, so it's unlikely to be added in the near future.
I didn't mean to come out as angry sorry! It all makes sense, I just wonder how the heck the author of Computable manage to have it working on iPad. True, that app was pulled from the store, but I had it for a while and it was working pretty well.
My App has integrated numpy, matplotlib, scipy, scikit-learn, now migrating scikit-image. https://twitter.com/MobileAnalyser
Seconded! Scipy for Pythonista would be really great for scientific computing.
@paanvaannd Add a thumbs up on the original issue if you'd like to see this implemented
@omz http://apple.stackexchange.com/a/157502/133916 looks like a solution that people have had success with in the past that doesn't involve Fortran to C translation
So, a year down the line, any progress on the matter? Having SciPy or an equivalent is quite detrimental for my consideration on whether to get Pythonista for scientific data analysis on the go
I would definitely need scipy on iOS, being used as a basis in hundreds of open source project on the scientific computing.
I hope to have good news soon...
I'd argue that many of the most useful modules from SciPy in iOS programming are backed by C/C++ modules notably signal and image modules.
The Fortran backed stuff is obviously useful (optimization etc) but IMO understable omission given toolchains.
Another Scipy and Pythonista aficionado here, I would love the app even more with Scipy :)
https://apple.stackexchange.com/a/157502 describes cross compilation w/ Fortran support, might make this issue feasible
Anyone got a straight answer about this issue? All i’ve been seeing is users asking for implementation
The official answer is no, there is no scipy in Pythonista. omz has never said whether or not he wants to add scipy at some point, but it doesn't seem like that will happen in the near future. I think he's well aware that it's an often requested library, but if it's not something he wants to add at the moment, that is his decision.
If the build for numpy were open sourced, we could probably adapt for SciPy, to lower work required for omz
@maedoc @controversial @zaino This guy seems to have done it, although in a different app (sadly, no longer in the App Store): https://github.com/ktraunmueller/Computable/blob/master/python-ios/scripts/build-scipy.sh
that's a neat trick, to use f2c, but curious if that actually works wtih scipy.
I’d love to know whether ios12 has brought us any closer to having scikit-learn on Pythonista, or the iPad in general. Without this, there seems to be no point in adopting Pythonista for data science purposes.
As a temporary alternative such a solution: https://forum.omz-software.com/topic/4200/data-analysis-workflow/17
I’d love to know whether ios12 has brought us any closer to having scikit-learn on Pythonista, or the iPad in general.
it's a toolchain/compiler problem, not a iOS version issue: SciPy has parts written in Fortran which isn't supported by the iOS toolchains
Without this, there seems to be no point in adopting Pythonista for data science purposes.
iOS isn't a great place to be doing data science tbh
I will agree with this. I use my ipad and phone mostly for data collection. Or simple things. I then move the data to my server or laptop which has much more processing power to actually do the full analysis of the data. Tho it would be cool to have some of the signal stuff thats in SciPy but there are pure python packages that can do that.
I'm wondering if there is any alternative of Griddata of Scipy for iOS development that you could suggest.
On Android, there is a python compiler “pydroid” which can compile c,c++ and fortran, so it can install python packages even they contain native code. I hope the same thing can be done on iOS(maybe it’s not so easy because Android is quite different from iOS)
