obo-relations icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
obo-relations copied to clipboard

NTR: 'administrates' and 'is administrated by'

Open jmwhorton opened this issue 1 year ago • 6 comments

Note: 'administrates' is currently in OBIB (http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/OBIB_0000733). 'is administrated by' is new.

NTR 1

Preferred term label

administrates

Textual definition

a administrates b if c owns b and some rights and obligations grounded in the owning relation regarding b are transferred from c to a.

rdfs:comment

A definition of "tranfers" object property can be found in d-acts: http:purl.obolibrary.org/iao/d-acts.owl

Term Editor

Mathias Brochhausen

NTR 2

Preferred term label

is administrated by

Textual definition

Inverse of ‘administrates.’

Term Editor

Clint Dowland

jmwhorton avatar Apr 13 '23 15:04 jmwhorton

On the call the following issues where brought up:

  • The word 'administrates' is not quite correct. It should be 'administers'. E.g. see: https://www.beedictionary.com/common-errors/
  • Administers is has very broad usage (e.g., administers medication). Is there a modifier you can use use in the label to make it more restrictive. Or perhaps use: manage, oversee, supervise etc.

wdduncan avatar Apr 25 '23 16:04 wdduncan

Any updates on this?

wdduncan avatar Jun 20 '23 14:06 wdduncan

Per 6-22 OBIB call, 'Administers' sounds fine. @CDowland Will take a look at the suggestion about the label.

jmwhorton avatar Jun 22 '23 19:06 jmwhorton

@jmwhorton @CDowland any updates on this?

wdduncan avatar Jul 17 '23 13:07 wdduncan

My apologies for not posting any updates prior to this month's RO meeting. We will follow up before the next one.

CDowland avatar Jul 18 '23 15:07 CDowland

Below are the revised NTRs, followed by an overview of the changes:

NTR 1

Preferred term label appointed administrator of

Textual definition a is an appointed administrator of b if c owns b and some rights and obligations regarding b, and that are grounded in the ownership of b, are transferred from c to a.

Term Editor Mathias Brochhausen, Clint Dowland

NTR 2

Preferred term label has appointed administrator

Textual definition Inverse of ‘appointed administrator of’.

Term Editor Clint Dowland

Changes:

  • Dropped the rdfs:comment because it refers to an obsolete term.
  • Replaced the label "administrates" with "appointed administrator of", and replaced "administrated by" with "has appointed administrator." The use of "appointed" here is to better reflect that the administrator, as the definition entails, is someone other than the owner. Granted, there may exist positions to which one can appoint oneself, and so "appointed" on its own does not entail the appointing person and the appointed person are distinct. But in this case the owner would already have the rights/obligations in virtue of being the owner, while the appointed administrator has those transferred to them in virtue of being appointed to the position.
  • Revised the phrasing of the first definition to be clearer.

CDowland avatar Aug 03 '23 19:08 CDowland