Magic-UV icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
Magic-UV copied to clipboard

Published 20 hours ago • verified publisher icon nutti

[5.1.0] Smoothing / Aligning doesnt work like original tool

Open schroef opened this issue 6 years ago • 4 comments

I tried using the smoothing and aligning tools again in UV Magic. But i cant seem to get the same result as in the original UV_Tools. I dont understand the extra "select" checkbox.

Here are some issues ill try to list;

Straighting method When i use the align method with magic, the uv swirls around, doesnt aligna or make it atraight at all. Here's a comparison UV magic screen shot 2018-06-01 at 2 07 37 pm

uv_tools screen shot 2018-06-01 at 2 07 46 pm

Aligning (there is no align button??) When use X/Y which is a boolean in uv-tools, the mesh moves over the uv island, it doesnt make it straight or align its verts. screen shot 2018-06-01 at 2 10 29 pm With each click the uv gets more deformed.

Second click screen shot 2018-06-01 at 2 11 12 pm

Third click screen shot 2018-06-01 at 2 11 38 pm

Circle options nags about last face needs to be a triangle, which the original doesnt do

Some cosmetics for the UV inspections Perhaps it makes more sense for the "UV Inspection" to have the eye show/hide icon instead of the play/pause icon?

schroef avatar Jun 01 '18 18:06 schroef

Straighting method Aligning (there is no align button??)

These two issues are same issue as #79 , aren't there? I'm tackling there issues but I could not have time to fix it.

Some cosmetics for the UV inspections

Great feedback. I will change icon.

nutti avatar Jun 02 '18 01:06 nutti

No i dont think these are the same, i did not get errors this time. I do see them when i turn of the X or Y though. DOnt remember which one, i can do some more check and that part.

The thing is that they outcome just doesnt work, Align and straighten doesnt show the correct result as the original uv_tool does. This is not about error output as in #79

Look at the screengrabs, they sort of show the issue im trying to explain

schroef avatar Jun 02 '18 07:06 schroef

Some cosmetics for the UV inspections Perhaps it makes more sense for the "UV Inspection" to have the eye show/hide icon instead of the > play/pause icon?

I revised the whole current UI which launch modal mode. You can try it from develop branch now.

nutti avatar Jun 16 '18 05:06 nutti

@schroef

And it will be helpful to send me pull request if you have a good idea about UI. You may have good user experience about UI because your continuous contribution.

nutti avatar Jun 16 '18 05:06 nutti