numix-core icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
numix-core copied to clipboard

Is system-restart an app icon?

Open palob opened this issue 3 years ago • 3 comments

Another one which is present in the base theme and possibly should not be included in the app icon themes.

palob avatar Oct 29 '21 10:10 palob

In most systems, the reboot function is not considered as an application entry.

At least in KDE Plasma icon list (with the numix circle theme installed), there is a group named "actions". Filtered by the term reboot, you can see these results:

image

There are no results returned for the term reboot in the applications group:

image

Considering this case, i think the reboot itself is a reference to a system action/job.

On the other side, if we consider a system action reference as a formal call to a group of resources or a command execution, it can be considered as an application, indeed. So, to set a rule to determinate or filter if something is an application or not, the criteria could be, for example, the .desktop extension.

KBeDevel avatar Nov 09 '21 15:11 KBeDevel

Thank you for sharing your insights. I think the icons were added because some DEs show(ed) those in menus just like app launchers. These days I guess there are more cases where the app icon will look out of place than cases where it helps.

palob avatar Nov 09 '21 18:11 palob

Just noticed this is/was being addressed in #4585.

palob avatar Dec 19 '21 21:12 palob