numix-core icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
numix-core copied to clipboard

System Settings icon

Open pgera opened this issue 8 years ago • 7 comments

The system settings icon looks too much like an on/off switch. Something with either a gear or a wrench, as it is conventionally represented, would be a lot more intuitive.

pgera avatar Jan 16 '17 00:01 pgera

Actually, I think our icon implements a widely-used and established metaphor for settings. It looks like the switches you'll find in the system settings.

Anyway, I'm open to discussion. While we are at it - we've got quite a few icons designs involving switches, cogs or physical representation. Maybe it's not always a plausibe representation for the app in question

palob avatar Jan 17 '17 22:01 palob

Perhaps more than one switch would make it more obvious ? It's the single switch that makes it look like an on-off switch, especially when it's on the launcher. See the last icon on the launcher, for instance.

screenshot from 2017-01-24 23 10 19

pgera avatar Jan 25 '17 04:01 pgera

@pgera Just a small question, why aren't using Numix Circle and you're using Numix base instead?

bilelmoussaoui avatar Jan 25 '17 04:01 bilelmoussaoui

@bil-elmoussaoui Just a matter of taste. I prefer the base icons over the circle ones. I find the circle icons to be over-simplified to the point that they convey less information.

pgera avatar Jan 25 '17 04:01 pgera

In this case it's an issue for https://github.com/numixproject/numix-icon-theme. Since Numix is designed to be used combined with Numix Circle/Square the icon in question (it's the lowermost in your screenshot, light?) usually won't be picked for system settings.

palob avatar Jan 25 '17 08:01 palob

That's where I had opened it originally. https://github.com/numixproject/numix-icon-theme/issues/1179

pgera avatar Jan 25 '17 08:01 pgera

@pgera Sorry about that! I thought that you meant the Circle/Square icon. Can you please reopen the other one instead of this issue ? Thank you

bilelmoussaoui avatar Jan 25 '17 09:01 bilelmoussaoui

Closing because using just Numix base is an unsupported use case.

palob avatar Oct 27 '24 23:10 palob