qaac icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
qaac copied to clipboard

native resampler not bitstream identical with iTunes

Open Bleuzen opened this issue 7 months ago • 1 comments

Hi, I want to do encodes like iTunes with qaac. According to the wiki this command should do it:

qaac64.exe --no-smart-padding -v 256 -q 2 <infile>

This works perfectly for files which are in 44.1 kHz already. But not other samplerates. iTunes does resample all audio to 44.1 kHz so to do the same I guess the command should be:

qaac64.exe --no-smart-padding -v 256 -q 2 --rate 44100 --native-resampler <infile>

but this does not produce the same output as iTunes.

I tried line, norm & bats complexity but none are the same as iTunes. Is this a bug? If not, what are the settings iTunes uses?

Bleuzen avatar May 22 '25 16:05 Bleuzen

iTunes could do whatever Apple wants for trivial tasks such as resampling, and why do you think I know what they are doing when it is closed source?

nu774 avatar May 23 '25 08:05 nu774