Can we split modbus-stream into modbus-stream-core and modbus-stream

[lygstate]

trafficstars

So that we can use modbus-stream-core in bare-metal environment.

[dresende]

If you want the common modbus part, there's modbus-pdu which this module uses.

[lygstate]

If you want the common modbus part, there's modbus-pdu which this module uses.

I wanna use stream.js only and provide own driver

[dresende]

This module has very little maintenance nowadays. I would advise you to fork and make your changes. You can make a pull request in the end and we can integrate.

[lygstate]

This module has very little maintenance nowadays. I would advise you to fork and make your changes. You can make a pull request in the end and we can integrate.

If you have no objection, I'd like create an fork that only contains the core part. can you create a stream-core repository for me and give me admin permission in node-modbus?

[lygstate]

This module has very little maintenance nowadays. I would advise you to fork and make your changes. You can make a pull request in the end and we can integrate.

Another option is move stream and transport from node-modbus/stream to node-modbus/pdu, which prefer?

[dresende]

I think it would be better to have modbus-pdu with just the modbus package. We could think of having an hierarchy like:

• modbus-stream-<some transport>
  • modbus-stream-core
  • modbus-pdu

Or something similar..

[dresende]

I sent you an invite as admin to https://github.com/node-modbus/stream-core

[lygstate]

I think it would be better to have modbus-pdu with just the modbus package. We could think of having an hierarchy like:

• modbus-stream-<some transport>

  • modbus-stream-core
  • modbus-pdu

Or something similar..

Like this idea, can you create a repository stream-core, I wanna do the initial work

[lygstate]

I think it would be better to have modbus-pdu with just the modbus package. We could think of having an hierarchy like:

• modbus-stream-<some transport>

  • modbus-stream-core
  • modbus-pdu

Or something similar..

I'd like do it in two stage, first split modbus-stream-core out, then the drivers.

[lygstate]

I sent you an invite as admin to https://github.com/node-modbus/stream-core

Do you have objection to use github actions? I wanna convert the CI from travis to github actions

[dresende]

I sent you an invite as admin to https://github.com/node-modbus/stream-core

Do you have objection to use github actions? I wanna convert the CI from travis to github actions

Feel free. I also use them in new projects 😃

[jacobq]

@lygstate as you are refactoring, could you please consider also adding support for passing in an external transport? e.g. for a ModbusTCP client, instead of having to call modbus.tcp.connect(port, host, options, callback) it'd be nice to be able to pass an existing net.Socket object in, maybe something like this:

import { createConnection } from 'net';
import { ModbusClient } from 'modbus-stream';

function getConnection() {
  // treat as "black box" -- could be transporting over TLS/SSL, could be a test mock, etc.
  return createConnection(...);
}

async function main() {
  const someExistingConnection = getConnection();
  const mbClient = new ModbusClient(someExistingConnection);
  try {
    const result = await mbClient.readCoils(...);
    console.log(result);
    // ...
  } catch(e) {
    throw Error(`FIXME: handle Modbus errors`);
  }
}

[lygstate]

@lygstate as you are refactoring, could you please consider also adding support for passing in an external transport? e.g. for a ModbusTCP client, instead of having to call modbus.tcp.connect(port, host, options, callback) it'd be nice to be able to pass an existing net.Socket object in, maybe something like this:

import { createConnection } from 'net';
import { ModbusClient } from 'modbus-stream';

function getConnection() {
  // treat as "black box" -- could be transporting over TLS/SSL, could be a test mock, etc.
  return createConnection(...);
}

async function main() {
  const someExistingConnection = getConnection();
  const mbClient = new ModbusClient(someExistingConnection);
  try {
    const result = await mbClient.readCoils(...);
    console.log(result);
    // ...
  } catch(e) {
    throw Error(`FIXME: handle Modbus errors`);
  }
}

Hi, PR at https://github.com/node-modbus/stream-core are welcome. I've merged pdu into https://github.com/node-modbus/stream-core for easier to improve stream. Now we can use webpack to pack it, (I assume), there is no depedencies to nodejs 'fs' anymore.