impermanence icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
impermanence copied to clipboard

The importance of persisting `/var/lib/nixos` is not documented

Open kuruczgy opened this issue 10 months ago • 2 comments

The examples do show /var/lib/nixos being persisted, but it's never mentioned that doing so is vital to the correct functioning of the UID/GID allocation mechanism of NixOS.

If /var/lib/nixos is not persisted, UIDs/GIDs are allocated sequentially, and so can shift around across boots if new ones are added to the configuration. It can happen that after a reboot, a file is now randomly owned by a different user.

The documentation should warn about this, and as a longer term solution I would suggest adding an assertion: Only allow /var/lib/nixos to not be persisted if all users/groups have explicitly declared ids.

kuruczgy avatar Apr 04 '24 20:04 kuruczgy