plaid
plaid copied to clipboard
nickbutcher
Bug: scrolling down, I can't see the toolbar anymore
It also doesn't re-appear later . Only when I scroll all the way to the top.
@ataulm Exactly. Thank you for putting a reference animation about the issue.
@kstoyanov5 So you've found the cause to the bug, then. A large list that you have to scroll all the way to the top to show the toolbar. Not UI friendly.
@AndroidDeveloperLB it's not but this concerns the design of the app so it will be the best if @nickbutcher shares his mind on the issue.
@kstoyanov5 It's not what? You said that this is the cause to this behavior, no? Do you know of any Google app that allows to show the toolbar only if you reach the top of a huge list?
Look, it's on the guidelines too: https://material.io/components/app-bars-top/#behavior
Sorry for the misunderstanding I meant that it's not user friendly. Yes, this is the cause of the behavior but they have implemented it in this way intentionally. There are many approaches for fixing this issue but as I said this concerns the design so I wouldn't leap into fixing it unless there is a green light from the product owner.
@kstoyanov5 Isn't the purpose of this project to demonstrate how an Android app could follow the guidelines, or something?
Hi @AndroidDeveloperLB I think you're on point here. But please take the Readme of the project into the consideration as well. It might help to put some insight into this discussion.
@rhlmshr Still a bug. if you like quotes:
"showcase material design in Android in a real application...with UI logic in Android classes".
Also, pretty sure the part you've added is newer than the bug report.