elmarmalade icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
elmarmalade copied to clipboard

expired certificate for marmalade-repo.org

Open tpapp opened this issue 7 years ago • 12 comments

It apparently expired on July 12, 2018.

tpapp avatar Jul 12 '18 11:07 tpapp

As foretold in #106, it might take a while, but hopefully we can get another three-year renewal :)

aaronbieber avatar Jul 12 '18 15:07 aaronbieber

FWIW, I had very good experience with https://letsencrypt.org/. One can set up the renewal automatically.

tpapp avatar Jul 12 '18 15:07 tpapp

https://letsencrypt.org/2018/08/06/trusted-by-all-major-root-programs.html

tpapp avatar Aug 07 '18 18:08 tpapp

Letsencrypt is definitely the way to go forwards. It's free, and once setup, it features automatic renewal.

What's not to like?

josteink avatar Aug 15 '18 08:08 josteink

Emacswiki now considers this repository as discontinued, so perhaps the best course is to consider it abandonware.

tpapp avatar Sep 05 '18 05:09 tpapp

The last comment was from ~18 months ago, but this is still happening...

acaird avatar Mar 09 '20 01:03 acaird

keep-alive ping - this is still problem

sleep-walker avatar Aug 16 '20 11:08 sleep-walker

And today.

danverbraganza avatar Nov 16 '20 19:11 danverbraganza

It's still going on.

ypsilon-takai avatar Sep 29 '22 08:09 ypsilon-takai

I’m no official representative for marmalade, nor do I in any way have the authority to speak on its behalf…

That said: This is a production-stopping bug which has persisted for more than 4 years, without Nic ever, not once, responded, acknowledged it nor promising a fix.

That’s almost half a decade.

Marmalade as an alternate repo is gone. People aren’t publishing there anymore and haven’t for 4+ years. If it ever gets back online, it will exclusively contain obsolete or broken packages.

It’s dead.

Thanks @nicferrier for running marmalade for us over the year. It was greatly appreciated!

But as a community, we have ELPA, non-GNU ELPA and MELPA to rely on, and there’s no point keeping marmalade around as a zombie. It’s time to let go.

(And maybe even @tpapp can close this issue to acknowledge that?)

josteink avatar Sep 29 '22 13:09 josteink

@josteink: I don't understand what closing an issue that is unfixed has to do with signaling that a repo is abandoned. It may remain unfixed forever, but I don't see how closing it would help.

The maintainer can archive the repository and then all issues would be frozen.

Yes, this project seems to be anadoned, cf #158.

tpapp avatar Sep 29 '22 13:09 tpapp

I mean the issue is fixed/resolved since we as Emacs-users still have plenty of repos to choose from.

And as things are now, reviving marmalade will only make things worse, not better.

josteink avatar Sep 29 '22 16:09 josteink