AarogyaSetu_Android icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
AarogyaSetu_Android copied to clipboard

Is this source code even legit?

Open riderattitude opened this issue 4 years ago • 11 comments

On Twitter, according to some reports this code is not an open source code.

riderattitude avatar Jun 02 '20 15:06 riderattitude

Could you share those tweets to verify your concerns?

sreejeet avatar Jun 02 '20 17:06 sreejeet

Could you share those tweets to verify your concerns?

https://mobile.twitter.com/jackerhack/status/1266971326918455298

riderattitude avatar Jun 02 '20 17:06 riderattitude

I agree, this code doesn't really match the real APP. Lots of 'views' are missing such as 'Home', 'Chatbot' and other important modules.

adheep avatar Jun 02 '20 19:06 adheep

I agree, this code doesn't really match the real APP. Lots of 'views' are missing such as 'Home', 'Chatbot' and other important modules.

So here you are its totally fake for making us busy.

riderattitude avatar Jun 03 '20 11:06 riderattitude

I agree, this code doesn't really match the real APP. Lots of 'views' are missing such as 'Home', 'Chatbot' and other important modules.

It might not be the updated one. Did you find it completely different?

shubham201 avatar Jun 04 '20 03:06 shubham201

Refer https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qU16qhccknQ&feature=youtu.be by @asdofindia

tachyons avatar Jun 04 '20 06:06 tachyons

I agree, this code doesn't really match the real APP. Lots of 'views' are missing such as 'Home', 'Chatbot' and other important modules.

This app uses webview to load this url https://web.swaraksha.gov.in/ncv19/

gopalindians avatar Jun 04 '20 13:06 gopalindians

I agree, this code doesn't really match the real APP. Lots of 'views' are missing such as 'Home', 'Chatbot' and other important modules.

This app uses webview to load this url https://web.swaraksha.gov.in/ncv19/

Thanks for that, it makes sense now.

But not sure if it fair to call it open-source, because most of the issues are on the webview for example alignment of the buttons at the bottom. But currently, we don't have an option to contribute to the majority of the features on the app.

adheep avatar Jun 04 '20 17:06 adheep

I agree, this code doesn't really match the real APP. Lots of 'views' are missing such as 'Home', 'Chatbot' and other important modules.

This app uses webview to load this url https://web.swaraksha.gov.in/ncv19/

Thanks for that, it makes sense now.

But not sure if it fair to call it open-source, because most of the issues are on the webview for example alignment of the buttons at the bottom. But currently, we don't have an option to contribute to the majority of the features on the app.

My opinion: They(whosoever controls the Aarogya setu app code legally)have chosen the fastest way to track people with the help of this approach, if they choose to go by native development the development/delivery loop will be slower. That's why the webview.

They have opened the source code for security researchers, not for accepting other contributions through GitHub. As GitHub is an non india based company, they will not open their development/release flow here, if they choose to release whatever they release will be a snapshot of code at particular point.

None of the government controlled apps were relased publicly like this previously, I think that's a good start.

I wish the open source development increases in and around the goverment apps/websites.

नमस्कारम

gopalindians avatar Jun 06 '20 15:06 gopalindians

https://pib.gov.in/PressReleasePage.aspx?PRID=1626979

vivek-owwit avatar Jun 11 '20 04:06 vivek-owwit

https://pib.gov.in/PressReleasePage.aspx?PRID=1626979

Thanks for the link.

gopalindians avatar Jul 15 '20 07:07 gopalindians