amptk icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
amptk copied to clipboard

Species names in amptk_mock2.fa and amptk_mock3.fa vs Figure 4

Open peterjc opened this issue 2 years ago • 0 comments

Cross reference #87, amptk_mock1.fa was earlier work and does not have species names.

Pulling out the species names,

$ grep "^>" amptk_mock[2-3].fa | cut -f 2 -d ">" | cut -c 5- | sort -n | uniq
1 |FP170182|Phialocephala fusca
2 |RF10JR|unknown Ascomycete
3 |FP170134|Phialocephala lagerbergii
4 |FP170235|unknown Ascomycete
5 |RF1JR|Aspergillus candidus
6 |RF3JR|Bjerkandara adusta
7 |GDL-1|Laetiporus caribensis
8 |RF5JR|Trametes gibbosa
9 |OR2|Laetiporus gilbertsonii
10 |MR5-1|Gloeoprus pannocinctus
11 |FP72612|Wolfiporia dilatohypha
12 |FP170198|Schizopora sp
13 |FP170231|Fomitopsis ochracea
14 |L34-2|Laetiporus cremeiporus
15 |RF9JR|Phanerochaete laevis
16 |DA37|Laetiporus cincinnatus
17 |RF7JR|Puntularia strigooszonata
18 |IN4-1|Phellinus cinereus
19 |MR5-3|Antrodiellla semisupina
20 |TJV93-174|Leptoporus mollis
21 |RLG7163|Leptoporus mollis
22 |FP170186|Mortierelllales sp
23 |HHB9564|Laetiporus percisinus
24 |FP170215|Penicillium nothofagi
25 |FP170177|Pochonia suchlasporia
26 |MD275|Wolfiporia cocos

Now comparing these to Figure 4 https://doi.org/10.7717/peerj.4925/fig-4 by eye (since sadly the figure is an image), most agree:

  1. Phialocephala fusca
  2. unknown Ascomycete --> Ascomycete sp.
  3. Phialocephala lagerbergii
  4. unknown Ascomycete --> Helotiales sp.
  5. Aspergillus candidus
  6. Bjerkandera adusta (cross reference #86)
  7. Laetiporus caribensis
  8. Trametes gibbosa
  9. Laetiporus gilbertsonii
  10. Gloeoprus pannocinctus
  11. Wolfiporia dilatohypha
  12. Schizopora sp
  13. Fomitopsis ochracea
  14. Laetiporus cremeiporus
  15. Phanerochaete laevis
  16. Laetiporus cincinnatus
  17. Puntularia strigooszonata
  18. Phellinus cinereus
  19. Antrodiellla semisupina
  20. Leptoporus mollis
  21. Leptoporus mollis
  22. Mortierelllales sp
  23. Laetiporus percisinus
  24. Penicillium nothofagi
  25. Pochonia suchlasporia -> Metapochonia suchlasporia (homotypic synonym)
  26. Wolfiporia cocos

Note the paper mock2 and mock4 have changed from "unknown Ascomycete" to "Ascomycete sp." and "Helotiales sp." respectively. Also, mock25 was updated from the homotypic synonym to "Metapochonia suchlasporia".

None of these three are discussed by name in the paper, so this does not seem very important, but still might be nice to update the FASTA files here to match the paper.

peterjc avatar Dec 01 '21 17:12 peterjc