tasks icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
tasks copied to clipboard

[Feature Request] Assign users to tasks

Open mastobuuthnaath opened this issue 8 years ago • 38 comments

Steps to reproduce

  1. Create one User
  2. Create a second user
  3. Create a task for the first User
  4. Assign this Task to the second user

Expected behaviour

This Task shall be visible by then by the second user

Actual behaviour

This functionnality doesn't exist yet ?

mastobuuthnaath avatar May 04 '17 15:05 mastobuuthnaath

In the description of this app there is written that one can share tasks with other users. But I cant find this option to share? Where can I find it?

thanks a lot for your response!

Walhalla

walhallaRV avatar May 15 '17 02:05 walhallaRV

I agree,please add the ability to do the task access to other users.

pvl-e avatar May 23 '17 16:05 pvl-e

+1 The ability to share tasks would be a great feature!

elronzo avatar May 26 '17 08:05 elronzo

Agree. Sharing tasks would be great. Am using shared calendars right now and it can be a bit cumbersome

tschiu avatar May 28 '17 13:05 tschiu

This should be implemented so one could share a complete task list or only single tasks.

andreasjacobsen93 avatar Jun 13 '17 10:06 andreasjacobsen93

This seems to be a more detailed duplicate of #14.

cwmke avatar Jun 30 '17 19:06 cwmke

+1 It's really important en enterprise to share a task with an other user.

FitzChevalerie-22 avatar Aug 02 '17 07:08 FitzChevalerie-22

Just another view regarding the sharing of tasks: I would like to assign users to tasks, so it is possible to delegate tasks to other team members. Is this the plan or is this another issue, like I think the author of #99 wanted to see. Or do I hassle things?

dartcafe avatar Oct 21 '17 13:10 dartcafe

Is there any plan to implement this functionality? It's kind of essential for shared tasks environment.

zefir6 avatar Nov 08 '17 11:11 zefir6

the current way that sharing task lists works is explained in #14 Share task lists.

here is a way how you can use this to assign tasks to people in your team:

  1. create a new calendar in the calendar app and name it for example "to be done by team-memberXY"
  2. still in calendar app, share the calendar with that user (with the option "can edit") (depending on the structure of your team, decide who can see&edit whose calendards/task lists)
  3. now in task app, if you have a task and want to assign it to someone, simply move it (drag&drop) to this new calendar/task list

SehLax avatar Jan 02 '18 15:01 SehLax

What is the current status? This feature would be really nice :)

Pokerkoffer avatar Feb 25 '18 20:02 Pokerkoffer

I am very interested in this function cause then I could really collaborate within nextcloud.

@SehLax: The key about widely spread software is it's user experience. This seems rather complicated to me. An unexperienced user would never find this solution easy to understand. Is there maybe a way to make all this a little bit easier? Just take a look at Open-XChange and their task functions. This is pretty simple to use.

Cheers

GoetheG avatar May 19 '18 03:05 GoetheG

+1, we work in a small team and most kanban boards are over the top. The task app in NC is perfect. Just need to be able to assign it to team members....

dosch avatar Nov 01 '18 14:11 dosch

Could I suggest to implement this simply as a category, but as a separate field on the task, so that on the backend it would be a category, but when you are on the "Assigned to User" field, you have a drop-down of users to select from to whom you can assign the task. Then when you have a shared task list between some members, then you can simply filter out tasks by user category. Or if using a category in the backend is a wrong way to do this then maybe it could be a separate column in the database - though I haven't looked at the Tasks app code and I don't know how it's actually implemented.

We are currently a small team of 3 people and we are using Categories as a way to assign the Task to a user, but having a dropdown of users list would be better.

User_Task_Mockup

I would be willing to implement this myself with some guidance/mentoring from the nextcloud team if there would be a consensus on how this feature should be implemented.

TruputiGalvotas avatar Mar 11 '19 22:03 TruputiGalvotas

@TruputiGalvotas a user dropdown would be awesome, but the category solution doesn't fit for bigger teams. I think instead of a dropdown the Nextcloud typical text input with auto suggestions would be enough. We are a whole school using Nextcloud for parents, teachers, students. We have classes as groups, e.g. one group for all parents of one class. We have rotating jobs like cleaning service, every weekend a different family (this is a private school with 36 students per class). So we make a Task list for cleaning service, each task is for one family. It would be great if we could assign these tasks to these families, that they get a reminder for "their" weekend.

wdfee avatar Jul 16 '19 18:07 wdfee

It's possible to share tasks by share task (calendar) with users / groups.

But task should be check permissions! Users mark tasks as done without permissions and it looks good for the user, but it's not syncing to task creator and other users. The user without change permission to the task calender should get an error message instead?

Assign tasks would be nice, following here.

pwFoo avatar Jul 20 '19 13:07 pwFoo

But task should be check permissions! Users mark tasks as done without permissions and it looks good for the user, but it's not syncing to task creator and other users. The user without change permission to the task calender should get an error message instead?

Indeed, that is a bug. A user without editing permission should not be able to change a task's property locally. I created an issue for this: #522

raimund-schluessler avatar Jul 20 '19 19:07 raimund-schluessler

share!=assign

pcav avatar Dec 08 '19 15:12 pcav

Is this issue still open?

GoetheG avatar Feb 08 '20 21:02 GoetheG

To me yes

pcav avatar Feb 09 '20 05:02 pcav

Same here !

vincowl avatar Feb 09 '20 10:02 vincowl

+1

macmiranda avatar Apr 08 '20 13:04 macmiranda

+1 Any update ? It will be a great feature for tasks app... and it's very important for teammates to collaborate easily

steeve971 avatar Apr 16 '20 19:04 steeve971

After reading the CalDAV and ICAL specs I believe that I understand why this might be a bit trickier than expected.

A VTODO lives in a calendar, this calendar has an owner. You cant simply share a task, because its not how its is done. A task i my calendar is not connected to a task in your calendar. Ofcoure you could make a tast with ID T1 live in several calendars and if the task gets updated in one also update the task in all other places. I am not sure how the different software out there would react to this. But I assume that CalDAV does handle this.

I would assume that the way this would be done is that you create a project calendar and then create the task there, and the use the ATTENDEE and ORGANIZER fields to indicate who is the owner and who is interested in the task.

https://icalendar.org/iCalendar-RFC-5545/3-6-2-to-do-component.html

https://icalendar.org/iCalendar-RFC-5545/3-8-4-1-attendee.html

I assume that a good point to start would be to see how this is implemented in the EVENT component in the calendar. For there you can add people to an event.

dukeh3 avatar May 31 '20 22:05 dukeh3

You might also have a look at the Nextcloud Deck app. I heard that it is a caldav client nowadays, too.

szaimen avatar May 31 '20 22:05 szaimen

Is there any update on this? It would be nice to be able to assign a singe task to another user, like cards in Deck App.

annievoss avatar Apr 28 '21 18:04 annievoss

It irritates me a bit that after more than five years nothing has happened yet. This function is a standard in all Tasks/ToDo-Apps and required for various processes in collaborative work.

Der-K-2000 avatar Dec 23 '22 09:12 Der-K-2000

Hi there, I too would like to be able to assign tasks to user.

I'm currently trying to implement it. I'd really like to have some help from someone who understand how the task plugin work. The Task plugin is great but it lacks what seems to be very simple features that would make it even better.

DeepReef11 avatar Dec 30 '22 21:12 DeepReef11

For those who are familiar with the deck app which has this functionality already, is it possible to check if there is a way to use a bit of the code from there?

kenince avatar Apr 17 '23 15:04 kenince

Would be really great if this was added, surprised it's not an option yet still

I'm not surprised.

Just add a thumbs up to the original issue description at the top. Saves others having to scroll past "me too" comments with no additional information.

meonkeys avatar May 16 '23 16:05 meonkeys