Ask for camera and microphone access on macOS

[ShGKme]

Since macOS 10.14 Mojave it is required to ask media access on Mac.

What to do, if the user refuses?

https://www.electronjs.org/docs/latest/api/system-preferences#systempreferencesaskformediaaccessmediatype-macos

[fabricemous]

I did not explicitly refuse access I believe. Perhaps something I missed so how can I make Talk ask me access again. Or otherwise where can I change these in my system settings.

[gymnae]

Happened to me as well, the app did not request permission and I'm not able to use microphones or cameras

[wolfspyre]

yeah. seems like the cause is already identified and a PR exists to address from march https://github.com/nextcloud/talk-desktop/pull/80 What needs to happen to get that merged and a new build minted?

[gymnae]

macOS is not in focus until version 1 release, apparently

[bentuna]

I can confirm that under macOS 14 Sonoma the issue still exists: no asking for camera or microphone permission and therefore no usage for calls possible.

[cyr06]

MacOS Sonoma + Talk Version 0.29.0 (https://github.com/nextcloud-releases/talk-desktop/releases/download/v0.29.0/Nextcloud.Talk-darwin-x64-0.29.0.zip) I wasn't ask to allow mic and camera so impossible to make a call.

[ShGKme]

I will try to check this issue again next week 👀

[benjamindahl]

hey people, I've managed to get it to work. Coming from another problem I realised that Talk-Desktop does not ask for camera and microphone permission. I used https://github.com/DocSystem/tccutil to grant them with the following command manually:

Download or clone the python-script to your computer. Then run sudo /usr/bin/python3 ./tccutil.py -p /Applications/Nextcloud\ Talk.app -e --microphone --camera

[benjamindahl]

Suggestion: title of the bug should be changed to just macOS, because it affects all recent macOS versions

[crckrmn77]

hey people, I've managed to get it to work. Coming from another problem I realised that Talk-Desktop does not ask for camera and microphone permission. I used https://github.com/DocSystem/tccutil to grant them with the following command manually:

Download or clone the python-script to your computer. Then run `sudo /usr/bin/python3 ./tccutil.py -p /Applications/Nextcloud\ Talk.app -e --microphone --camera`

Can confirm this worked for me on M2 MBP running Sonoma 14.5.

[wolfspyre]

That's cool! Really. Neat find @benjamindahl THANK YOU FOR SHARING.

THAT BEING SAID, This is NOT A FIX but a (USEFUL) hacky workaround.

The fix is that the application must actually request the privileges it needs.... This is handled for talk by the browser, but as a standalone client, the permissions must be explicitly declared

(I believe the entitlement needs to be baked into the app cert too but I'm not a mac app dev ;) )

[andrewhotlab]

Using version 0.39.0 on macOS 11.7.10: it does not ask neither seems to be possible manually grant permission on mic and camera! :'(

[ShGKme]

Please, confirm that this problem still persist on v1 and which macOS version do you use.

[andrewhotlab]

The version 1.0 is working for us on macOS 11.7.x.

[ShGKme]

Thanks

[cyr06]

works fine great job !