desktop
desktop copied to clipboard
nextcloud
[Bug]: Update strategy for MacOS Big Sur
⚠️ Before submitting, please verify the following: ⚠️
- [X] This is a bug, not a question or a configuration issue.
- [X] This issue is not already reported on Github (I've searched it).
- [X] Nextcloud Server and Desktop Client are up to date. See Server Maintenance and Release Schedule and Desktop Releases for supported versions.
- [X] I agree to follow Nextcloud's Code of Conduct
Bug description
I need to state that the server and client are up to date, but putting the client up to date is the current issue.
I am on macOS big sur (11.7.10), and the Nextcloud client is version 3.2.3 and the client says 3.10.1 was available:
But the client there is just for macOS 12+, so for me it would be the legacy version for macOS 10+, but that is version 2.6.5, so much older than the version I already have. And there seems to be an issue as well #6179.
Unfortunately, I have to stick with macOS 11, however it is still a supported version. The Client version 3.2.3 is still running, some report (see the report on the issues on 2.6.5) that even the newer version is working. Why is the version not officially supported, just a lack of testing, problems of features?
Steps to reproduce
- Use macOS 11.7
- Use Nextcloud desktop client, until you hit version 3.2.3
- It recommends to update to 3.10.1, but this version is supposed to support only macOS12+ ...
Expected behavior
More details, why some version are supported / not supported any more. Help users with older versions, allow people to use older hardware.
Which files are affected by this bug
nextcloud
Operating system
Mac OS
Which version of the operating system you are running.
macOS 11.7
Package
Other
Nextcloud Server version
26
Nextcloud Desktop Client version
3.2.3
Is this bug present after an update or on a fresh install?
Updated from a minor version (ex. 3.4.2 to 3.4.4)
Are you using the Nextcloud Server Encryption module?
Encryption is Disabled
Are you using an external user-backend?
- [X] Default internal user-backend
- [ ] LDAP/ Active Directory
- [ ] SSO - SAML
- [ ] Other
Nextcloud Server logs
No response
Additional info
No response
Hello, in my opinion the problematic behaviour is that the client is inviting the user to upgrade the package, but then, once upgraded, the package won't work anymore. It sould be more "fair" and warn the user that the current MacOS version is in end of life for NC Desktop and stop any path to package upgrades.
In addition, I'd say that stopping support for a major OS version in a bugfix release (3.10.0 -> 3.10.1) is not very usual... I would expect such a change in a new major/feature version... my 2 cents
fwiw, the "legacy" version 2.6.5 didn't even work for me on MacOS 11.7.1 - it launches and immediately crashes, leaving only Nextcloud Extensions running in the Activity Monitor, and no toolbar icon. I think my v3 app had auto updated itself until it no longer worked. Not sure, I wasn't expecting it to be unsupported. Going to look for a download for the v3.2.3 that supposedly works.
fwiw, the "legacy" version 2.6.5 didn't even work for me on MacOS 11.7.1 - it launches and immediately crashes, leaving only Nextcloud Extensions running in the Activity Monitor, and no toolbar icon. I think my v3 app had auto updated itself until it no longer worked. Not sure, I wasn't expecting it to be unsupported. Going to look for a download for the v3.2.3 that supposedly works.
3.10.0 worked fine for me. (https://download.nextcloud.com/desktop/releases/Mac/Installer/)
@mgallien Mac OS version 11.x is the last supported version for e.g. all MBP Late 2013. It still receives security updates (latest was https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT213915) and there is no possibility to update to Mac OS version 12.x.
Can you consider rolling back the changes made in b15369c and continue support for at least version 11.x? I understand that supporting old OS versions is painful. But sticking to an old version of the nextcloud client is only a temporary solution.
This was the related pull request, but it is not clear why it requires a new MacOS version: https://github.com/nextcloud/desktop/pull/6174
Something is going on under the hoods: https://github.com/nextcloud/desktop/pull/6207
MacOS Big Sur 11.7 is a solid OS, it is still supported by Apple (gets regular updates). But even if it weren't, a client application has absolutely no right to force the user to upgrade the OS. As others have pointed out before me, the updater must test the current OS version and refuse to install if the new version happens to be incompatible with said OS.
Slightly off-topic but related bug: the MacOS client has an option in "Settings" that seemingly lets the user to turn off the check for updates:
But despite the unchecked checkbox it does check for updates and keeps nagging the user to upgrade.
And while we are at it: I personally see absolutely no reason to install each and every update. Version 3.9 of the MacOS client worked for me without a hitch, just like all versions before it that I can remember (your mileage may vary of course). Yes, I gave in to the nag screen several times ... but not any more, as I am not going to upgrade from Big Sur, thank you very much.
Parting shot: Donald Knuth famously said that "premature optimization is the root of all evil". If I may humbly paraphrase him: "Unnecessary upgrades are the root of all evil". Thank you.
MacOS Big Sur 11.7 is a solid OS, it is still supported by Apple (gets regular updates).
According my research November 2023 was the last security patch by apple and Big Sur has now officially reached EOL.
Yes, Big Sur is now officially EOL, but seeing as the 3.10.0 update still supported Mojave (10.14), dropping 3 OS releases in a minor update could be considered somewhat drastic..
As for the automatic update check, this has been an issue since about June 2022 if I'm not mistaken. There's been multiple attempts to fix it, but the behaviour remains the same.
Related issue: https://github.com/nextcloud/desktop/issues/5429
What's the latest working version? 3.9? I need to reinstall from https://download.nextcloud.com/desktop/releases/Mac/Installer/
after reinstalling 3.9 i immediately get the dreadful:
So i clicked "Skip this Version"
I have a Macbook Air from 2013 that I still use daily. The latest MacOS version available for it is MacOS 10.15.7 (19H2026) Catalina.
The latest version of Nextcloud sync client that works for it is version 3.10.0 (macOS "osx-19.6.0")
The client regularly prompts the user to upgrade nextcloud to 3.11 but that version cannot be opened on macOS 10.15 Catalina. MacOS simply refuses to open the app.
Note: I also tried nextcloud clients 3.10.1 , 3.10.2 and 3.10.3 : They aren't compatible either.
A related ticket: https://github.com/nextcloud/desktop/issues/6176
I must say, it was very frustrating experience to troubleshoot. This hurts the trust in Nextcloud's stability.
It would be great to have a legacy support version with limited features but endless compatibility and the choice to stay on that "update thread" to not be bothered with automatic system inavailabilty by update.
Is there a reason why the minimum version was bumped up so many versions?
There are a lot of reasons to stay on older versions, in particular 10.14 was the last macOS that can run 32bit apps.
The sync client is mainly C++ code, are they planning to switch to Apple’s File Provider API?
I love Nextcloud, and so it's a real shame, as Nexcloud usually pushes back on big tech to stop this sort of nonsense being the norm.
OS 12 in now the minimum to sync files? Really Nextcloud?
Perhaps skip a tiny bit of functionality to bring the masses along with your product and app rather than restricting users on apples terms.
Syncthing supports my wifes old mac and uses the latest version, so it's possible.
Please remove the tag "needs triage" we are talking about dying patients here that should be saved and not be triaged as "they are dead already anyways ..." see also https://wiki.bitplan.com/index.php/IT_Pain_Scale
I just ran into this. A good first start would be to update the "legacy client" link on the website to something that actually works. Anyone knows in which repository nextcloud.com website lives? I couldn't find it! 😿
