git-gateway icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
git-gateway copied to clipboard

Published 20 hours ago • verified publisher icon netlify

BitBucket support

Open pogo19 opened this issue 6 years ago • 7 comments

Please add BitBucket support, thanks!

pogo19 avatar Feb 02 '18 22:02 pogo19

Very interested in this as well. Github is all well and good, unless your project requires the use of private repositories, with minimal cost.

Wandern avatar May 19 '18 19:05 Wandern

Is there any progress with this issue? I totally agree with Wandern about this.

cNille avatar Oct 13 '19 12:10 cNille

It will be very nice to have BitBucket support too I'm in a situation where I need this for a project.

lauragift21 avatar Jan 26 '21 12:01 lauragift21

GitHub has had support for free Private repositories for a couple years now, so for those who held back on using GitHub for this reason, you can give it a try now 👍

ajmueller avatar Jan 26 '21 15:01 ajmueller

Echoing this request - I don't have the option to use GitHub for a project at work. It's crazy that the entire Netlify Identity service becomes useless when your repo is on Bitbucket. And I know this isn't the place for Netlify CMS but it's also weird this isn't explicitly called out in the docs there.

timtorres avatar Jul 19 '21 20:07 timtorres

And I know this isn't the place for Netlify CMS but it's also weird this isn't explicitly called out in the docs there.

Hi @timtorres, for the CMS docs see https://www.netlifycms.org/docs/git-gateway-backend/. Should we link to it from another part of the docs to make it more clear? Can you open an issue for it on the CMS repo of where you would expect it to be stated?

erezrokah avatar Jul 20 '21 10:07 erezrokah

@erezrokah Yes I went through that and the Bitbucket page several times trying to understand. It's more about the wording than the location, maybe a mention somewhere else could help also. It does give alternate instructions for Bitbucket but doesn't make it clear that it's ⚠️ not compatible with Netlify Identity (git-gateway) ⚠️, nor make clear the implications, etc. If we have more than 5 users, we'd now have to pay for a Bitbucket plan in addition to Netlify, and they'd all need repo access where before I could have unlimited editors interact with Netlify Identity only. These details and no clear roadmap for integration in the last few years would've had a direct impact on the stack I chose. I know there are alternatives but they're all a bit advanced for me.

But yes, sorry, this is just for context – I'll see if I can open an issue with some helpful suggestions.

timtorres avatar Jul 20 '21 11:07 timtorres