snmp-info icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
snmp-info copied to clipboard

Adding support for Mellanox switches device

Open SharonYeuda opened this issue 4 years ago • 17 comments

Is it possible to add support for Mellanox switches device? Mellanox VLANs

Here is the General info screen Mellanox Net Disco details page

SharonYeuda avatar Jun 14 '20 14:06 SharonYeuda

Hi, Any new?

SharonYeuda avatar Jun 25 '20 20:06 SharonYeuda

without the process detailed here: https://github.com/netdisco/snmp-info/wiki/Simulating-Agents#get-snmp-datadump better melanox support will most likely not be coming soon. we rly need to the data dumps detailed there to provide better support.

inphobia avatar Aug 10 '20 00:08 inphobia

Hi, I have upload an snmprec file to Add support for Mellanox #311

SharonYeuda avatar Nov 15 '20 10:11 SharonYeuda

the good news is that i was able to load up the snmprec file in my test setup. the bad news is that even after registering on the mellanox portal i was not able to download the required mibs. https://support.mellanox.com/s/downloads-center & other links to their mibs are a dead end for me.

to be clear, these are the ones i'm talking about: image

the link at the bottom of that screenshot goes to https://support.mellanox.com/ which gives me a image

i also tried the link in #311 ( https://community.mellanox.com/s/article/getting-started-with-snmp-mibs-for-mellanox-switches ) but still couldn't download the mibs

i think this is as far as i can go without getting those mibs. can you download them & email 'em to nick.nauwelaerts at aquafin.be ?

thx

inphobia avatar Nov 15 '20 16:11 inphobia

Hi, Here are all the latest MIBs. Hope this will help

MellanoxPrivateMIBs_3.9.1908.zip

SharonYeuda avatar Nov 16 '20 09:11 SharonYeuda

Hi, any new?

SharonYeuda avatar Nov 22 '20 15:11 SharonYeuda

thx for that, i just committed this to netdisco-mibs.

there are a few more pull & change requests i'd like to merge over the coming days. then i'll create a new release.

this does not mean snmp::info will suddenly support your devices, but with the snmprec & mibs we can start working on adding a mellanox class. now if only there were more hours in a day....

inphobia avatar Nov 26 '20 20:11 inphobia

Thank you very much for your effort..

On Thu, Nov 26, 2020, 22:33 nick n. [email protected] wrote:

thx for that, i just committed this to netdisco-mibs.

there are a few more pull & change requests i'd like to merge over the coming days. then i'll create a new release.

this does not mean snmp::info will suddenly support your devices, but with the snmprec & mibs we can start working on adding a mellanox class. now if only there were more hours in a day....

— You are receiving this because you authored the thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/netdisco/snmp-info/issues/396#issuecomment-734469731, or unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/ACN6SDZ3Z76DEDRJ6QTCNDDSR23R7ANCNFSM4N5PFQFQ .

SharonYeuda avatar Nov 27 '20 11:11 SharonYeuda

Hello Nick.

Sorry for bothering, Is there any new?

SharonYeuda avatar Dec 14 '20 16:12 SharonYeuda

Hi, Can anyone help with this please???

SharonYeuda avatar Jun 30 '21 12:06 SharonYeuda

thx for that, i just committed this to netdisco-mibs.

there are a few more pull & change requests i'd like to merge over the coming days. then i'll create a new release.

this does not mean snmp::info will suddenly support your devices, but with the snmprec & mibs we can start working on adding a mellanox class. now if only there were more hours in a day....

Hi,

Can you please outline needed steps to perform, to make netdisco support Mellanox devices?

Thank you!

susanin-ivan avatar Jun 30 '21 13:06 susanin-ivan

Hi inphobia,

Can you please replay?

SharonYeuda avatar Jul 28 '21 10:07 SharonYeuda

to add support for a specific device class we need::

  1. the mibs for the device. i forgot when i added them, but the latest release ( https://github.com/netdisco/netdisco-mibs/releases/tag/4.020 ) should have them.
  2. access to a device or snmprec dump of the device ( https://github.com/netdisco/snmp-info/wiki/Simulating-Agents#31-snmpsim--snmprec-version )
  3. and the hardest, someone with the right combination of spare time & some basic perl knowhow. ( https://metacpan.org/pod/SNMP::Info#Data-Structures-required-in-new-Subclass )

we would love to add support, but at least for me there are only so many hours in a day. if you want to give it a try we will surely support you via irc ( #netdisco@libera ) or email. keep in mind that all of us use irc proxies so it could take several hours or days before we reply there but we will see your messages and will reply if you remain online.

my experience is that supporting the basics (interface info & such) is straightforward most of the time. so, if @SharonYeuda or @susanin-ivan would like to give it a try we will do our best to support you any way we can.

inphobia avatar Jul 29 '21 22:07 inphobia

Hi @inphobia !

Thank you for this information, I'll give it a try

susanin-ivan avatar Aug 03 '21 16:08 susanin-ivan

Hi susanin-ivan,

Any new?

SharonYeuda avatar Aug 18 '21 11:08 SharonYeuda

Hi, any luck with this??? what "assigned-to-project" means?

SharonYeuda avatar Jul 09 '23 14:07 SharonYeuda

Here is the latest Mellanox MIB files

hop it helps

MellanoxPrivateMIBs_3.10.4302.zip

SharonYeuda avatar Jul 25 '23 09:07 SharonYeuda