alexa-youtube icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
alexa-youtube copied to clipboard

Why did you remove the code?

Open jamezrin opened this issue 4 years ago • 7 comments

Why out of the sudden you decided to privatize the code? It was fine like it was...

And you just created a commit removing the code, that's not really privatizing anything, you could've done much better by rewriting the git history.

I don't understand this move honestly, if you privatize do it correctly, not just a commit....

jamezrin avatar Dec 30 '19 23:12 jamezrin

Unfortunately more people were stealing my code and trying to profit off of it, than were trying to collaborate to help improve it. So I've removed the code. Sorry about that. Yeah I should probably delete the history, but I deleted the files in a hurry over Christmas.

ndg63276 avatar Dec 31 '19 13:12 ndg63276

Ok, I think I've removed the important files from the history.

ndg63276 avatar Dec 31 '19 14:12 ndg63276

No, well, people with forks are welcome to continue development of the code themselves. Generally though, people weren't very helpful. I've had 16 pull requests in 2 years, and most were just language updates. And then other people were profiting off my work. So I've decided it should only be me profiting off it. You can call me selfish if you want.

As for point 3, I've just removed the lambda_function.(py|zip) files from the commits, so it's not much use to anyone.

ndg63276 avatar Dec 31 '19 19:12 ndg63276

I don't think you are selfish by doing this, I think it's perfectly justified, but I don't think it makes sense. People will still be profiting off your work nonetheless, just not from your future work as you privatized it.

Who has been profiting off your work? I would like to know. If it's public, maybe try DMCAing it, in theory as you didn't include any license notice in your code, it is copyrighted to you.

jamezrin avatar Dec 31 '19 19:12 jamezrin

ah, I understand this decision but I'm very sorry. In my opinion, Amazon should have allowed you to publish them officially as done in other countries. How is it going, does it continue to work privately or is it blocked? my free aws account expired and therefore I had stopped using it, but it was very useful as a skill

mariodmmariodm avatar Jan 21 '20 20:01 mariodmmariodm

I was disappointed to notice that you had taken the project private but I understand the motivation -- I'm sorry to hear that people were profiting off of you. Thanks for your work, sorry to see this shut down. Tinkering with it was a good learning experience for me.

crd avatar Apr 26 '20 14:04 crd

Yikes. I'm glad I found this discussion; spent a good hour trying to find that dang 'ol lambda file. So disappointing as a DIY person.

nguyen-k avatar Nov 19 '20 03:11 nguyen-k