nats.deno icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
nats.deno copied to clipboard

Implement slow consumer detection in Nats.js

Open alphara opened this issue 3 years ago • 3 comments

We often experience slow consumers in our real-time system based on NATS. It is useful if the service would be able to detect itself as a slow consumer.

According to nats_admin/slow_consumers, there is a way to detect slow consumers with the NATS client on Go. The same feature is not implemented for the NATS client on Node.js.

Could you implement slow consumer detection in the Nats.js?

alphara avatar Sep 01 '21 12:09 alphara

@alphara this is a good idea. The javascript clients are more prone to this type of problem as they have a single thread to process inbound/outbound and user code.

aricart avatar Sep 01 '21 14:09 aricart

That's right. That's why we want to detect it.

The following graph shows how often we experienced slow consumers in our real-time system in the last 30 days. image

We have Node.js and Java clients in our system.

alphara avatar Sep 01 '21 16:09 alphara

@alphara trying to study how to reflect this - effectively if you are using callbacks, the messages are in the execution path of the socket read - the data read from the socket is parsed, and as parsed, it invokes subscriptions - there's no buffering here, on the particular data read from the network gets processed. If you are using iterators, that is a different story, because function that feeds messages into an iterator, buffer, so at that point it is possible to determine if there are messages pending. The subscription's getPending() actually has an approximation of how many messages have queued up for the subscription.

aricart avatar May 13 '22 22:05 aricart