react-uwp icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
react-uwp copied to clipboard

Font license issue

Open Saurer opened this issue 7 years ago • 8 comments

Excerpt from the Segoe MDL2 icons article https://msdn.microsoft.com/windows/uwp/style/segoe-ui-symbol-font

How do I get this font? To obtain Segoe MDL2 Assets, you must install Windows 10.

And as stated in microsoft typography faq https://www.microsoft.com/typography/faq/faq11.htm

What can I do with the fonts supplied with Microsoft products? The fonts are governed by the same restrictions as the products they are supplied with. You are not allowed to copy, redistribute or reverse engineer the font files. For full details see the license agreement supplied with the product.

That is: Segoe MDL2 font is not suited for MIT-licensed project or any other project at all because it can't be shipped with it

I'm looking forward to your response about this issue because i really like this project, but these issues can get users into some troubles

Saurer avatar Nov 06 '17 05:11 Saurer

With WinJS, they had to fallback to a font package that was similar to but still different from MDL2.
https://github.com/winjs/winjs/tree/master/src/fonts Some of those icons are kind of ugly though so an alternative to this alternative would be nice...

limefrogyank avatar Nov 30 '17 04:11 limefrogyank

Found a decent alternative: https://github.com/icons8/windows-10-icons

This one is free and has very limited set of icons. You can get more with paid version, but still - it is better than being sued

Saurer avatar Dec 11 '17 23:12 Saurer

@Saurer @limefrogyank thanks for attention, on the issue of font license agreement, I hope I can redesign a set of icon font, but it will take time.

myxvisual avatar Dec 12 '17 03:12 myxvisual

@myxvisual Is it possible to modify orionLibrary's icon and makes it fit the need of this Lib? It may reduce much work. https://orioniconlibrary.com/

Losses avatar Mar 17 '18 05:03 Losses

@myxvisual Is the redesign get started? I drew some icons to kill my weekend recently, maybe we can create a repo to work together?

my repo: https://github.com/Losses/fds-community-icons

Losses avatar Jan 26 '19 00:01 Losses

Intel's Clear Sans seems good. https://www.fontsquirrel.com/fonts/clear-sans

hendratommy avatar May 28 '19 14:05 hendratommy

Any update on this licensing issue? Unless changed, I believe everything developed using this package will be a subject of a copyright infringement due to inclusion of this folder which I guess is always included?

KeyWeeUsr avatar Nov 24 '19 14:11 KeyWeeUsr

I found this post which pretty much covers the case when people do npm build i.e. embedding of source code files and resources. In this case Segoe MDL2.

So pretty much either there is no useful answer or use https://github.com/Microsoft/fonts and move away from Segoe.

KeyWeeUsr avatar Nov 24 '19 16:11 KeyWeeUsr