music-encoding icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
music-encoding copied to clipboard

mei-CMN disallows accidental apparatus

Open rettinghaus opened this issue 4 years ago • 3 comments

<accid> is not allowed within <lem> and <rdg>, although <app> is allowed within <note>. It does work, if mei-all is being used.

Seems to be connected to #566

rettinghaus avatar May 27 '20 15:05 rettinghaus

The same applies to <artic> within <rdg>, as we've just noticed working on MEI 4-files at the Digital Interactive Mozart Edition. Are there any plans to allow <accid> and <artic> within <lem> and <rdg> in mei-CMN? We would appreciate that.

MirijamBeier avatar Oct 28 '20 14:10 MirijamBeier

@kepper @ahankinson Any idea how to fix this? I have none.

rettinghaus avatar Feb 05 '22 08:02 rettinghaus

We would have to see if model.noteModifierLike can serve as a good starting point (I haven't thought through yet if the <dot> in there may have side effects), and then make this a member of model.rdgPart.music. Without too much thinking about directions of memberships, this should come to the right end – at least it's worth a try…

kepper avatar Feb 05 '22 09:02 kepper