MuseScore icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
MuseScore copied to clipboard

[MU4 Issue] Playback not in sync with playhead when changing instrument in mixer

Open bkunda opened this issue 2 years ago • 4 comments

Describe the bug Note: similar to #14894, but with a different trigger

When substituting instruments in the mixer and then resuming playback mid-score, the substituted instrument alone recommences playback from the start of the score (concurrently with the playback at playhead position).

To Reproduce See demo video: https://www.dropbox.com/s/mx9ymh9rtbfihax/playback-sync-position-change.mov?dl=0

Expected behavior Substituted instrument should not recommence playback from start, but should instead sync with current playhead position.

Platform information

  • macOS 12.6 (M1)
  • RC (4.0.0.223411003)

bkunda avatar Dec 08 '22 15:12 bkunda

@Tantacrul @bkunda Very similar to #14902 , could be duplicate

pmarx810 avatar Dec 08 '22 17:12 pmarx810

@Tantacrul @MarcSabatella @RomanPudashkin also similar to the issue found in #14910

pmarx810 avatar Dec 08 '22 17:12 pmarx810

Thanks @pmarx810, all these issues do indeed seem very similar to one another. I'll keep this one open for now though because it contains a demo video, which is always useful for our devs so they can actually see what's going on. Thanks!

bkunda avatar Dec 09 '22 11:12 bkunda

@Tantacrul this one comes up often and I assume it would be a simple fix to consider for a patch

MarcSabatella avatar Jan 09 '23 14:01 MarcSabatella

@Tantacrul this one comes up often and I assume it would be a simple fix to consider for a patch

@Tantacrul This would indeed be good. Not sure how simple it is (although it can't be too complicated), but it would certainly be nice to get this fixed since it has come up quite a few times.

cbjeukendrup avatar Jan 29 '23 13:01 cbjeukendrup

I'd like to hear what @vpereverzev has to say.

Patch or 4.1?

Tantacrul avatar Jan 29 '23 14:01 Tantacrul

@DmitryArefiev can you please check this one again for validity/reproducibility?

bkunda avatar Aug 31 '23 14:08 bkunda

@bkunda Yes, still occurs (4.2 nightly master, MuseSounds, Win10).

Can't reproduce with MS Basic

DmitryArefiev avatar Aug 31 '23 15:08 DmitryArefiev

Also from #14894:

Steps to reproduce the behavior:

Play a score with the current instrument Stop the playback, don't change position of the play head Change instrument Start playback. Playback starts at the beginning of the score, while play head continues from current position somewhere in the score.

bkunda avatar Nov 17 '23 14:11 bkunda

Fixed in #20626

DmitryArefiev avatar Jan 08 '24 10:01 DmitryArefiev