MuseScore icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
MuseScore copied to clipboard

[MU4 Issue] Instrument name does not update in parts dialog and its tab on replace

Open HemantAntony opened this issue 2 years ago • 6 comments

(Updated by @Tantacrul, @DmitryArefiev ) Describe the bug When opening some older scores, the 'Replace Instrument' feature does not work. However, it does work for new scores.

BUG№1 - FIXED in #13097 To Reproduce:

  1. Open string quartet 2.zip
  2. Open Violin I part
  3. Go to score and replace the Violin I with another instrument, like a Flute, using the Instruments panel
  4. Observe that the instrument label in score/mixer and sounds do not update.

https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/90187801/190918230-036284c9-7ec6-4971-9e1f-ade697bb5a60.mp4

BUG№2 (STILL OCCURS) To Reproduce:

  1. Open string quartet 2.zip
  2. Open Violin I part
  3. Go to score and replace the Violin I with another instrument, like a Flute, using the Instruments panel
  4. Observe that the instrument name in part, in its tab and in parts dialog do not update.

https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/90187801/190918628-ed607a95-dde3-4545-a3eb-344fb7ff3031.mp4

Expected behavior The instrument's name should be updated in the parts dialog and its tab

Initial video from bug report

https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/88136054/146490932-a6ced8f6-6d20-4c0c-9d38-c2142dcf0a55.mp4

Desktop (please complete the following information): Win, Mac, Linux

HemantAntony avatar Dec 17 '21 04:12 HemantAntony

I am working on this

HemantAntony avatar Dec 17 '21 05:12 HemantAntony

I'm going to alter the description a little and escalate this. The issue is fixed for new scores. However, I have an older score where this doesn't work.

Tantacrul avatar May 30 '22 14:05 Tantacrul

I don't know how widespread this problem is anymore. It could just be an issue with my file, which was originally a MusicXML import into 3.6. Other comments welcome!

Tantacrul avatar May 30 '22 15:05 Tantacrul

I can still reproduce this in a similar way to my original example

Also if unclear, I'm no longer working on this. 5 months is too long :)

HemantAntony avatar May 30 '22 15:05 HemantAntony

OK, I've moved it to alpha then if you are still experiencing it.

Tantacrul avatar May 30 '22 17:05 Tantacrul

@RomanPudashkin Says there are two different issues here:

  • one about not updating sounds/name in Mixer
  • and another about not updating instrument name in part, in parts dialog and in part's tab

The issue №1 is fixed in #13097 The issue №2 still happens

I've edited the description to separate two issues

DmitryArefiev avatar Sep 18 '22 17:09 DmitryArefiev

@Tantacrul I moving this to Beta2 since the issue with changing sound and the name in Mixer is fixed now.

And also this issue is similar to #13239

DmitryArefiev avatar Sep 26 '22 10:09 DmitryArefiev

@DmitryArefiev - agreed.

Tantacrul avatar Sep 26 '22 12:09 Tantacrul

An interesting thing to note is that on other parts the name is updated, but not on the original. image image The name change shown here is from Trumpet 4 to Trumpet 3 (and the deletion of the old Trumpet 3). This is an issue for instrument name changes too, not just actual instrument changes. Edit: And the (old) Trumpet in B♭ 3 part is not shown here because I closed it; otherwise it is still an empty part that still exists (and shouldn't!), just like in #13239

woooowoooo avatar Oct 28 '22 04:10 woooowoooo

Fixed in #14288

DmitryArefiev avatar Nov 11 '22 15:11 DmitryArefiev