musicbrainz-userscripts icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
musicbrainz-userscripts copied to clipboard

Bandcamp importer: featuring artists bug

Open culinko opened this issue 7 years ago • 2 comments

It looks like Monstercat's Bandcamp page started standardizing "feat." into "featuring" and the importer script automatically catches that and splits the artists into two fields of artist credit and adds the "feat." join phrase, which is awesome! (The cover art and other sources for the same release still use "feat." and not "featuring", so I prefer to use that one over the standardized one). However there seems to be an issue in mb with re-using existing recordings and mb thinks the artist credit is different, even though it's exactly the same. The following is an example release where such bug occurs: https://music.monstercat.com/track/let-you-down and this is how the bug looks like: featuring artist-import script

Selecting the check-mark to update the recording artist credit has no effect, obviously. If I try to create the same release manually without importing it via the script, there is no issue:

featuring artist-normal

So I think it might be a bug with the importer script. Thank you for looking into this issue, much appreciated!

culinko avatar Nov 08 '18 22:11 culinko

I'm not sure this issue is due to the userscript, it looks to me it's an issue on server side instead.

@mwiencek @yvanzo : does it ring a bell on your side ?

zas avatar Dec 06 '18 08:12 zas

There is also a related bug when an artist is "credited as": https://tickets.metabrainz.org/browse/MBS-9789 , both issues happen when you try to re-use already existing recordings, so the cause might be similar.

culinko avatar Dec 06 '18 16:12 culinko