mtex icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
mtex copied to clipboard

different results using mirorientation volume function

Open ArneBoch opened this issue 5 years ago • 2 comments

Hello MTEX Team,

doing some investigations into misorientations and MDFs I got different results by volume calculations using volume with an vector of misorientations or volume of MDF calculated out of this vector - see below:

cs = crystalSymmetry('6/mmm',[1 1 4]); % fits nearly to the system I use mori = orientation.byAxisAngle(Miller(0, 0, 0, 1,cs,'UVTW'),30degree); ori = orientation.byEuler(0,0,0,cs); r_mori = inv(ori.rand(2000000,cs)).ori.rand(2000000,cs); r_mdf = calcMDF(r_mori); volume(r_mori,mori,25degree) volume(r_mdf,mori,25degree) ans = 0.0525 ans = 0.9993

First answer is ok I guess?

By the way to generate this random misorientation vector I could not use:

r_mori = mori.rand(200000) because it gives orientations but mori is mentioned as "misorentation" at Matlab Command Window?

I'm using Matlab 2017b and MTEX 5.2.8.

Thanks for help.

Arne

ArneBoch avatar Jan 17 '20 10:01 ArneBoch

Hi Arne,

thank you very much for this bug report. The command volume(r_mdf,mori,25*degree) indeed gives a wrong result.

For your symmetry you can resolve the issue by changing in file mtex/geometry/@symmetry/fundamentalRegion.m the line

maxPhi1 = max(pi/2,maxPhi1/2);

into

maxPhi1 = maxPhi1/2;

Remark: the syntax you use to generate misorientations is not correct. You should do

r_mori = orientation.rand(10000,cs,cs)

Ralf.

ralfHielscher avatar Jan 28 '20 20:01 ralfHielscher

Hello Ralf,

thanks for the hints.

Two more questions relating to this:

"For your symmetry" means this change is only vaid for hexagonal lattice?

If I have a misorientation (comming out of measurements for instance), is there a function/script to calculate nice mapping representation of it (epitactical relation) like plane p1 onto p2 and direction d1 onto d2? It would be the inverse of the mapping definition of a orientation: mori = orientation.map(p1,p2,d1,d2,CS1,CS2).

Thanks for help.

Arne

ArneBoch avatar Jan 30 '20 08:01 ArneBoch